An anime where a 94-year-old man is resurrected in a fantasy world where he attracts a harem due to being "ideologically sound without any deviant beliefs" is canceled for hidden references to the Rape of Nanking. /r/Anime discusses.

176  2018-06-07 by pitterpatterwater

164 comments

No wonder you have an army of pretentious neckbeard losers following you around

Snapshots:

  1. This Post - archive.org, megalodon.jp*, archive.is

I am a bot. (Info / Contact)

Anime is trash, isekai anime is ten miles below sea level kind of trash and directly responsible for the decline of Western society.

If you want your fill of island chink media read rapey (or straight up rape) visual novels instead.

I have yet to see a good isekai.

- /u/pitterpatterwater in 70 years, on his deathbed

I don't really watch anime, but I do read the occasional light novel. I tend to stay away from isekai because they're garbage, but I did have someone recommend one to me that I kind of liked, '俺の死亡フラグが留まるところを知らない'

Short synopsis is: Lead character wakes up in possession of the body of a minor villain from his favorite RPG video game. The twist is, he can't control his mouth (he talks like the villain) and everyone interprets his actions as villainous. He decided to play it up (act the part) while trying to avoid dying in the fight he knows is coming by exploiting his knowledge of the plot of the game.

There's an English translation floating around there that I've heard isn't half bad, but I read this in moonrunes and it's slightly above the normal complexity of a light novel in this genre. Also, it mostly avoids or subverts the common tropes that you might expect.

My kanji is pretty bad (I'm slowly working my way through 雪国 Snow Country) so I've found that light novels are a good way to help my literacy, but yeah... most of them are really bad. But what can you expect from YA fiction?

Isekai is basically SI fiction, if SI fiction was actually published.

Also, why are LNs so anime-ish? That certainly isn't the case for western YA, which at least try not to be pandering trash.

Because you're only being exposed to ones that get translated either by weebs or for weebs. Imagine if all English literature was translated into other languages by Harry Potter slash fic fans. That's basically what you're dealing with.

I learned conversational Japanese a while ago, but my reading was always poor because I couldn't be fucked to learn the 2000 kanji you need to graduate highschool. Anyway, when I started to put effort into learning it and was looking for things to read, I realized quite quickly that 'fan translations' are done by people who are more or less fucking morons. It's no surprise what type of projects they do.

Idk, LNs in general have anime covers.

Also, Twilight is better written than 99% of LN.

Unironically no, I've seen fanfics by people whose first language obviously isn't English better written that twilight.

I learned conversational Japanese a while ago, but my reading was always poor because I couldn't be fucked to learn the 2000 kanji you need to graduate highschool.

Imagine learning how to speak one of the hardest foreign languages and still being basically illiterate. Should've done Core10k + Tae Kim like every Japan-obsessed gaijin.

Speaking isn't actually that bad... once you get conjugation down, Japanese is actually kind of simple and you can be very vague in how you talk and it's still mostly alright. There are a few stupid idiosyncrasies, like the million different counting systems that are based on the size and shape of items you are counting, but it's nothing like trying to memorize 8 different readings of a stupid pictograph and then multiplying that by a couple thousand.

Plus, I'm old, so I literally need a magnifying glass sometimes to even guess what the fuck I am looking at.

trying to memorize 8 different readings of a stupid pictograph and then multiplying that by a couple thousand

Cause that's a poor way of learning Kanji. You should learn vocabulary, not readings. I'ts better to know words like traffic, street, fucking mail order even than knowing 通 can be read as to, tou or tsuu and IN ONE CASE kayo.

counting systems that are based on the size and shape of items you are counting

LOL fuck them, 1つ 2つ everything like a proper baka gaijin would. (don't do that)

I'm old, so I literally need a magnifying glass sometimes to even guess what the fuck I am looking at

I'm 20ish and I use the windows magnifier sometimes too and my eyesight isn't all that bad. Btw 蹂躙 is my favorite 'fuck your eyes' word.

Hardest languages

> Fake easier Chinese

Lol, you don't know what you're talking about.All LN ARE anime ish, that's literally their defining trait, according to the japanese themselves.

Western YA does not try not to be pandering trash lmao

Because you have the cause/effect relationship backward.

The LNs come first, then they get optioned into anime because it's a proven money maker. It's like asking why superhero comics are so much like movie.

Doesn't explain why they typically have anime drawings on the cover.

That's just later editions of the volumes after the anime has been released because an anime cover is more catchy.

This is complete bullshit.They always have anime covers right from the start.

That's just the currently popular aesthetic. You see the same art style in trendy manga too.

It makes sense for manga since it shares an art style with anime.

So do light novels.

You realize most of them have tons of art inside, right?

LN are basicly anime books, most of these people don't know what they are talking about.In japan LN are disctinguished from other novels by having anime style illustrations and anime-ish stories and characters.

NERRRRDDDDDDDDDD

minor villain

So it's I Reincarnated into an Otome Game as a Villainess With Only Destruction Flags but not gay a "romance" ?

How much time did it take to learn most of the grammar?

People who watch anime should be gassed

school setting anime

Uhhh something something prestigious academy Something something student council Something something school fair? Uhhhh

escaflowne? rayearth? dunbine? watch more anime loser

watch more anime loser

🤔🤔🤔

I didn’t think escaflowne was isekai, i thought everyone in it was from the world, so no fish-outta-water stuff

wrong

Hilton was from Earth. One of the villains was as well.

Except the main character, Hitomi, who literally came from another world.

No

those were isekai before isekai

the second they labelled it, everything went to shit

Alice in Wonderland was bretty güde

why don't you go kiss a truck in traffic and see what happens? Report back to us.

Escaflowne and konosuba are pretty good.

Watch KonoSuba then.

Yeah, it's probably one of my favorites.

That one was fun because almost every character is a parody. I don’t watch much anime so I didn’t even know there was a set genre for this

I'd say Log Horizon was pretty fun to watch and No Game No Life was short enough to be worth watching.

Also is that anime about picking up girls in a dungeon an isekai? I'd say it's similar enough... It was fucking ecchi trash but I loved it.

Also is that anime about picking up girls in a dungeon an isekai?

No one in that one came from the real world so no. It's just fantasy.

NGNL is one of those shows that's far better than it has any reason to be. All it had to be was a generic isekai harem ecchi bullshit show. And you know what? It kind of is those things. It ticks off just about every box for each of those tropes. Pulled into another world, female-heavy cast, fanservice shots, etc. But somehow it manages to be a to more than that. The art is gorgeous, the characters are a ton of fun, it mocks itself (and everything else) all the time, and it manages to stay interesting throughout.

I really wish we'd gotten a season two.

good taste

oh /r/anime in my /r/drama? feelsgudman

KonoSuba is a great comedy isekai, and if you want a meme-worthy parade of death and despair, Re:Zero is also worth it.

I've heard a ton of good things about Re:Zero but haven't gotten around to it yet. Definitely on my plan-to-watch list though.

It's kinda hit or miss for me. I don't like it nearly as much as pretty much everyone else seems to. There are some really good parts but there are also some pretty terrible parts for me. I dunno, it's one of those things where I feel like people are so desperate for there to be a good isekai show that they latched onto it because it's decent in a sea of garbage.

Re Zero is actually terrible, and were well past the point of it being worth it for the memes.

I watched KonoSuba because my friend said it was a good isekai and I wanted to seppuku myself. It's fucking dogshit.

I think you may have been taking it seriously you were not supposed to do that

Not really, I went in looking to laugh and I honestly didn't even know when I was supposed to it was so unfunny to me.

In addition to Escaflowne and MKR mentioned before, .hack//sign sort of counts.

Jumanji 2?

I was actually super impressed, I heard about it before even seeing the trailer/who was in it and thought it would be just absolute shit but it was so good i've watched it 3 times with diff people now lol

Re:zero, that's about it.

Inuyasha

Knights and Magic is decent as long as you get past the visual aesthetic.

The Saga of Tanya the Evil is legit awesome.

I've hear Grimgar is good, but i haven't seen it.

Konosuba, obviously, is decent.

And beyond the anime, there's a lot of Isekai LNs and some are quite interesting.

B O N E D A D D Y

Re:zero is pretty good

Adding 12 kingdoms and fushigi yuugi to this dog pile.

Monster Rancher?

Isekai, harem, ecchi is the unholy trinity of anime trash.

I'll stick with a combination of moe, slice of life, CGDCT rather.

I'll stick with a combination of JoJo, JoJo, and more JoJo.

Jojo is gay, not in a bad way or anything, it just is.

Thanks for the input, /u/YameteOniichanItai

This but unironically

I have to see an isekai manga without harem or ecchi. Fuck there genres, especially harem.

Fuck you harem is the best sub genre

Fuck you it’s pathetically idiotic 100% of the time

Fuck you it's the perfect equilibrium in order to satisfy all shippings

Fuck you it’s the same five or six stock girl types used over and over again, who wants to ship that shit i do

Fuck you high school DXD is the best anime there ever was and that is a harem anime therefore harem is best.

Fuck you the best is obviously Eromanga Sensei

You both need to be gassed.

pls daddy

If it's harem where the mc is too retarded to know he has one it's trash.

I agree

Then you haven't read Alice in Sexland.

Try Tensei Shitara Dragon no Tamago Datta The manga isn't far but the LN translation is far enough and its not a bad read.

If you realtalk want something that doesn't involve that then check out Cavalier of the Abyss, Gunjou Senki, Shut Hell, and Grimgar of Ash and Fantasy.

moe, slice of life, CGDCT rather.

Moeshit is garbage.It's just a different side of the same coin.

Do I even want to know what isekai is?

In the thread it says something about going to a new fantasy world or something? I don’t fully get it either honestly

From what understand it encompasses all animes where the main character “goes to another world” or “starts over” etc

Think Narnia but more Japanese.

So, Narnia with fuckin'?

Currently popular genre of japanese fantasy where someone from our world is put into a fantasy world. Sometimes they die and get reincarnated, sometimes a portal opens up and sucks them in, something they're summoned deliberately as a hero.

The best of them tend to function as effective deconstructions of typical fantasy genre tropes with the main character as audience surrogate. The worst are basically self-insert fanfiction.

You say that, but Konosuba inherits all of those aspects and is really good, but that might be because it satirises many of those aspects.

No, that's exactly why it's good.

chink media

Jap media bro. Get ur slurs straight.

Nah, calling it chink media triggers both the japs and the chinks.

Does anyone on this board really have the right to call anything "trash"?

mathematicians talk about maths

geologists talk about geology

trash talks about trash

I'm a bot, bleep, bloop. Someone has linked to this thread from another place on reddit:

 If you follow any of the above links, please respect the rules of reddit and don't vote in the other threads. (Info / Contact)

I don't mind Isekai but holy shit is it over done now. One show got popular and all of a sudden everyone decides to copy and follow it. Honestly the genre is old as fuck.

Those who hunt elves is a good and there was another about three girls who became magical girls in a fantasy world and just wanted to go home.

Today's anime is slowly getting worse as waifu-trash taints everything around us.

What's the show that got popular and started this shit? Also what's the one about the magical girls?

The one with the magical girls is: Magic Knight Rayearth (I haven't see in it in forever).

The show that got it really popular was Re:Zero. I remember it being really popular when it came out but then others followed. Same waifu bullshit, same style, etc. Some mixed it up though like Overlord (max character in MMO gets teleported to the world he played in with all his skills.)

My favorite is still Resturant from Another World only because it skips what makes the copycats so awful.

Lol, Re:Zero didn't start this shit. The novel only started in 2012 and there was plenty of Isekai on Shosetsuka before that. Even the anime came after other stuff. Which should be obvious since Re:Zero's entire point is deconstructing the popular tropes established by prior works.

If you want to talk about the origins of Isekai, you need to go all the way back to stuff like El-Hazard, Fushigi Yugi, Escaflowne, Inuyasha, etc.

Yeah but Re:Zero was the one every tried to copy lately. Thats where it seemed to pick up steam.

Don't get me wrong there were literally dozens of entire animes around it but we really saw an explosion of it only recently. To the point where a publisher put out a statement saying "Stop sending these kinds of works"

Yeah but Re:Zero was the one every tried to copy lately.

It's really not.

A bunch of other really popular Isekai were written before it. And even got anime/manga adaptations before Re:Zero. And most have entirely different plotlines, themes and stories. It's just not accurate to say that most of the current Isekai explosion is recent, or that they were copying Re:Zero.

I mean, for fuck's sake even Re: Monster started in 2011. So not even the title of Re: Zero is that original.

Maybe Re:Zero is where you first heard of it. And maybe it's the one you like best. But it is absolutely not the originator of the trend.

I first heard of it with Magic Knight Rayearth and "Those Who Hunt Elves".

Wasn't ready for the second one to be honest. Thought it was completely different.

Meanwhile Zipang 2 never

Dang it's really ballsey what japanese war romanticizers are able to get away with. It'll be like someone's neo-nazi harem fanfic getting a netflix release in the west.

You gotta hand it to Japan, they’ve somehow gotten away with pretty much never apologizing for war crimes, continuing to have an emperor who is hailed with Banzai cheers by government officials, and returning to the flag of their ultranationalist government. Imagine if Germany in the 90s had just said fuck it and gone back to the imperial style flag

The Imperial flag doesn't have the stigma of a Nazi flag tho.

And it's also much more aesthetically pleasing then the dumb boring tricolor they're stuck with now

The japanese dont have a tricolour flag you retard.

I think he was talking about the German flag

Yeah, I know. Apparently he has no idea how to shift subject because his English teacher was a fucking mongoloid and he was too busy huffing glue to learn the bare minimum of how to write sensibly.

The absolute faggot.

Guilty as charged

It does in like most of SouthEast and Eastern Asia.

I was talking about the Imperial Germany flag you bussy-huffer.

I don't know what that word means, but it looks like I'd be very distraught if called that.

No it doesn’t. Most people won’t even recognise it ffs

Germany would've been better for it.

would be more efficient to draw on paper because I wouldn't have to color a third of it

thats the secret to their success, theyre imitating america

They learned it from MacArthur I suppose

Then again I've never heard anyone denying the Rape of Nanking.

Well...they do in Japan.

It's because the Japanese are just so darn cute and charismatic.

It's a bit more complicated than that. There have been apologies made by various Japanese officials over the years, albeit of questionable sincerity, including some by the current emperor, and Abe was elected more for his economic policies than because he pledged to MJGA. The Japanese were extremely pissed off when his wife was caught funding the Japanese equivalent of the Hitler Nursery, too.

But yeah, when your government is literally run by Imperial cultists, something has gone terribly wrong.

Holy shit I didn't realise you linked to srd and almost died from all the pearl clutching about cleansed chinamen.

Imagine the Chinese, busy killing each other for the past few hundred years for shit like slightly different pronunciation or spelling of the word 'bamboo' and then the island pictogram thieves barging in and saying they want a piece of that ass too.

I just looked it up and the things they did were horrific. Especially to children. I'm on the verge of tears.

You were not wrong about the histrionics.

also, i thought this stuff was common knowledge? people haven't heard of Most massacres but this and the holocaust and the Armenian massacre are among the more common ones i thought.

Americans

From what I've found a lot of people without any interest in military history have no knowledge of atrocities committed in the United States.

Attacking a military base is the worst thing ever but bombing millions of civilians is justified because anime.

Modern American opinion

Attacking a military base owned by the most powerful country in the world because you're an imperialistic Jap cunt is retarded and kind of evil.

Though I may be salty because they tortured Aussie POWs and have yet to apologize. God I hate Japanese culture

kind of evil.

Attacking a military base is evil? Gee no wonder you say "civilians deserve to die" but muh poor soldiers

God I hate Japanese culture

Yet weaboo americans eat loli porn like nothing.

Attacking a military base so you can take over the entire Pacific Ocean is pretty fucking evil, yes.

Reeeeetard.

Pretty flimsy justification. Yet bombing millions of civilians is perfectly just because the mayo culture doesn't sicken you.

Pretty flimsy justification.

TFW imperalistic invasion isn't a good justification for considering someone evil.

Also people obviously don't give a fuck about Hiroshima and Nagasaki because innocent people died because shitloads more civilians died in conventional bombing in Tokyo alone, let alone the rest of the world.

People care because atom bombs are scary.

Also people obviously don't give a fuck about Hiroshima and Nagasaki

bombing pearl harbor was evil though

See you reinforced my point. As long as mayos do it, it's fine for you. Hell the only thing you people whine about more is the holocaust where more white people died even though there's been ten massacres about the same size since then.

Also people obviously don't give a fuck about Hiroshima and Nagasaki ** because innocent people died because shitloads more civilians died**

Take your ADHD medicine.

holocaust where more white people died

Jews aren't considered white, retard.

Take your ADHD medicine.

Sorry I'm not a mayo teenager planning to shoot up a school anytime soon but you'd downplay that to drug medications.

Jews aren't considered white

Wait.... that would make jews actually the wealthiest and most powerful demographic in all of America, single handidly wiping out the "white privilege" argument for anti-semitism. Tread carefully shitlord.

Wait.... that would make jews actually the wealthiest and most powerful demographic in all of America

Fucking duh. I don't suppose you know how much money the USA gives to Israel, do you?

Tread carefully shitlord.

LOL. Who do you think you're talking to right now?

Who do you think you're talking to right now?

SOme fucking loser /r/drama user trying to redpill or jewishpill me fuck if I care

So why the fuck would I give a shit about the feelings of jews?

Because you care about white people so much.

Jews aren't white...assuming that "white" is even actually a thing and not just an idea in the minds of racist dipshits.

And I don't care about white people that much, I just hate the Japanese.

It IS common knowledge.

At least to everyone who didn't sleep through their middle school and high school history classes. Literally every coverage of WWII covers the rape of Nanking.

Which is why the reactions are so hilarious. It's like someone claiming they only just now found out that slavery happened.

It was taught, but no one gave a shit about asian history in schools.

Cant acknowledged Japan doing something do awful so close to the bombing of Hiroshima.

we've discussed this on the drama discord a couple times coupled with "I've seen hentai that reminds me of this so it's probably inspired by it"

jeez all it was was some chinese girls shishkababed

lol weeb shit who cares

Mfw isekai has destroyed the straight fantasy genre and now I'm sad.

At least Goblin Slayer is good albeit edgy as fuck

straight fantasy genre

Henkyou no Roukishi - Bard Loen

Flat old school Knight fantasy is what i'd recommend

I will check it out thanks

Np I like Fantasy too, only other one I can think of off the top of my head besides Gob Slayer and the spin off is

Maou-jou de Oyasumi but it's more of a comedy about a Princess kidnapped by the Demon King

What about Overlord?

Overlord is the exception, not the rule

I've read all the lns released so far so I'm thirsty

Konosuba

Is good and I enjoy but I want more serious pacing too

isekai has destroyed the straight fantasy genre

Bullshit. New non-isekai fantasy anime continues to come out every season as always.

Very few and most are generic game spin off harem bs.

Manga even less.

Goblin Slayer is good but it may as well just be Hentai at this point. It seems like the author can't go one fucking chapter without mentioning how much those pesky goblins love to rape women so much.

I have no experience with the light novel but if you've been reading the manga or the spinoff prequel manga the rape has quickly taken the backseat.

Certainly the author does seem to have a bit of an obsession over it but it doesn't feel nearly as prolific as the earlier chapters.

Also grimdark gore manga featuring a stoic protag with a sick helmet is 100% my niche.

I haven't read any of the recent chapters so that would probably explain it, but yea I agree with you that it's nice to have a full on grimdark fantasy setting which is why I said I thought it was good.

srd Lol

That is not why I expected it to be cancelled.

Harem anime is fun because it's impossible to tell the difference between parody and genuine content.

Lol It's fantasy you fucking nerds. It doesn't matter if he puts that in a story. I guess they have a right to pull it if they wanted to, but what don't these pussies complain about these days?

yo is this sub new? I never noticed it on the homepage before but now it wont go away. Who ever is making posts for this is so petty, anything i've seen within this sub makes me hate this site. I can picture all the annoying people from every other corner of this site congregating here and circle jerking arguments to fill there daily catch of tears and cap locks. any one that likes this place I hate you and mostly and one else in your life probably hates you, low key or not.

This should be a Snappy quote.

Okay, this is epic.

Wow, I thought Japan was safe from the enforcement of political correctness by SJWs because they're a homogeneous society that doesn't have any (((diversity))). It's sad to see even Japan fall to the disease that is SJW ideology.

Tbh you're a retard if you don't think cancelling a comic because of hidden genocidal messages isn't just common sense.

That thread is peak smug srdines. As usual

This really shows the directors of those animation companies are completely unaware of their source material. Who in their right mind would look at this and think "yup, this would go well with our Chinese viewers"?

This is when the Korean side of me kicks in. To dismiss this kind of issue as trivial/SJW-esque or as the Chinese/Korean attempt to sabotage a Japanese artist? Learn the fucking history and get back to me. Personally I don't understand how the US in general can be so japanophile after the Pearl Harbour attack and so many soldiers died in Asia Pacific.

/u/makeitcool So you think that Americans should be suspicious of Japanese media because of Pearl Harbor? This is the kind of retarded reasoning that is weirdly acceptable when it comes from a left-wing imbecile yet would be mocked relentlessly as bigotry by SRD if they had any self-awareness.

/u/makeitcool Because you squinty-eyed yellow bastards fought against my pals MURRICA in the Korean War I downvote every Korean on reddit, hope you understand.