The wheelchair :marseyjoe: dnd heroes drama has resurfaced once again

https://x.com/marysunshine_7/status/1769768725501128979

Once thought a meme, now an actual talking point for leftoids (I even seen one unironically post making a wheelchair dnd thing on heroesforge).

It's that thing once again, leftoids are trying to push a certain thing in a fantasy hobby that fits their political worldview of idealism that usually makes no sense and requires even more suspension of disbelief than roleplaying in a magic land with dragons and unicorns.

WHEEL :#marseyclapping2: CHAIR :#marseyclapping2: ACCESSIBLE :#marseyclapping2: DUNGEONS:#marseyclapping2:

WHERE IS THE ADA ON THIS?

Anyway there is plenty of "right wing extremist" dunking on the thread, so I picked some replies/subthreads from lefties since those are more interesting to read.

Reading all the comments here, there's so much vitriol for just wanting for disabled people to be treated equally.

They WILL pull their weight because they ARE heroes, simple as that.

:#marseyindignantretardtalking:

Complete with PF card for said wheelchair

https://i.rdrama.net/images/17108710855106268.webp

Some friendly fire:

https://x.com/StrixObscuro/status/1769843234568638931

Few more choice pearlclutching.

https://x.com/OddishHime/status/1769994460786499808

https://x.com/AquamarineFB/status/1769858783075766663

Last time I read a thread on this I think the "adventureres wheelchair" I saw was something that basically couldn't be broken unless there were two crits against it, which makes you wonder why not every wagon and vehicle was made with this cheap wheelchair technology. These people can't even design something with some risk because they're so afraid of losing so they need an invulnerable wheelchair.

And why even a wheelchair? Learn to levitate or something. If you're a wheelchaired martial character just go home :#marseyxd:

103
Jump in the discussion.

No email address required.

Chariots?

https://i.rdrama.net/images/17108738538898907.webp

Giant goblin mechas?

https://i.rdrama.net/images/171087385395557.webp

Magic carpets? (for Allah's children)

https://i.rdrama.net/images/17108738540045376.webp

These are all non-problems that were already solved. Your inability to integrate them into your worldbuilding is a skill issue, not one of ability.

Jump in the discussion.

No email address required.

:marseysalat:

Jump in the discussion.

No email address required.

chariot sure, but good luck with stairs or hallways, they'll have to just wait outside for most dungeons

flying carpet works but is usually a pretty high level item in most systems, odds of them surviving that long without it are pretty slim and it'll frick with party balance just handing it to them at the start

big mech has the same problem with the added bit that they'll probably need to be a specific class and it might not exist in the setting

players who want this usually come down to 2 categories:

  • just want free op shit and think they've found a reason you have to give it to them

  • want "i'm disabled" to be what they have instead of a personality

either way it's not gonna be interesting, and you're gonna have to contort your world around their bullshit with absolutely no payoff.

and you'll probably hate the player who brought it up anyway for other reasons

just tell him he has to crawl or be carried for the first 10 levels and move on with your game

Jump in the discussion.

No email address required.

want "i'm disabled" to be what they have instead of a personality

I would never do this in D&D because I already do it irl and I'd like some escapism.

Jump in the discussion.

No email address required.

Have you ever tried to navigate a narrow passageway on a flying carpet?. Those things corner like a cruise ship

Jump in the discussion.

No email address required.

What about a palanquin?

https://i.rdrama.net/images/17109084693561828.webp

Jump in the discussion.

No email address required.

seems reasonable, but it probably can't fit around tight corners or deal with terrain more difficult than stairs. ladder? narrow ledge? cliff you have to scale? tough luck.

probably some complication with the bearers too, they're either going to take enemy fire or have to come out of cover and get in position before every time you need to move

at that point you're probably better off just strapping yourself to a servant, if you can get one noticeably bigger than you it should have approximately all the benefits of a palanquin with some of the drawbacks removed

Jump in the discussion.

No email address required.

Get an ogre you raised from childhood to carry you around

Jump in the discussion.

No email address required.

Chariot

Mech

Flying Carpet

>breathes deep

Infinite teleport patron

Organic tentacles due to experiment gone wrong

Being part animal / transforming

Levitation

A necromancer that uses the undead to carry them around

I mean I could go on forever but like this is JUST your legs being broken.

A blind monk

Dumb people

Alcoholics

Cyborgs

Like come on

Jump in the discussion.

No email address required.

You forgot the master blaster one where you take someone who's mentally disabled and have them carry around the character who's physically disabled. It actually works best because the combined sum gets you a full person.

Jump in the discussion.

No email address required.



Link copied to clipboard
Action successful!
Error, please refresh the page and try again.