Personally paying taxes is what drove me to the left. That those tax dollars are being distributed so poorly really pushed me to wish for reform and improvement.
I never really understood people that became libertarians over taxation at all, they were too dumb and naive to attract me.
This is libel, and harassment - a civil tort, and a violation of the Reddit Content Policies.
The comment has been reported to Reddit administration. You have been banned from this subreddit. I reserve the right to sue you to reclaim damages to my reputation, and to pursue criminal charges against you. Reddit is likely to suspend your account.
I reject the idea that the the ability to own private property is the defining characteristic of an economy. It would be like defining modern cars as round wheel cars to differentiate them from the square wheel cars some crackpot claimed would be more efficient. It raises the silly idea of communism to a level where it can be compared to current real world economic systems despite never being able to exist for any real period of time.
Private property and personal property are two different things. Personal property exists in communism. And no private property is not the defining characteristic of capitalism, the defining characteristic of capitalism is that it creates a society wherein all commodities are produced for value and not use. You should try reading some theory before you shit on entire branches of thought like a little baby.
I've read kapital, the criticism of what he called capitalism is fine, great at points but he does prescribe anything usable because he was a hegelian and thought his vision of communism was just inevitable in the way trade liberalization described by Smith seemed to be. He was wrong, just like he was wrong about phrenology.
I’m not sure what that means. If that means you have studied the basics of Economics, what attracted you to Marx’s theories? Do you subscribe to the labor theory of value?
This is libel, and harassment - a civil tort, and a violation of the Reddit Content Policies.
The comment has been reported to Reddit administration. You have been banned from this subreddit. I reserve the right to sue you to reclaim damages to my reputation, and to pursue criminal charges against you. Reddit is likely to suspend your account.
The communist is immunized against all dangers. One may call him a layabout, parasite, ignoramus, NEET, it all runs off him like water off a raincoat. But call him a manchild and you will be astonished at how he recoils, how injured he is, how he shrinks back: “I’ve been found out!”
Do you think people aren’t basically wage slaves under communists regimes? Do you think they let people just not work? And it’s bad since it doesn’t work on large scales until a more technologically advanced society can sustain it but that’s another matter from your silly Venezuela poor people straw man.
I have no illusions about shitty state-capitalist countries but if you think that your neoliberal capitalist countries somehow produce any less suffering you're a fool.
A completely nationalised economy in a representative democracy could be considered a form of democratic socialism, since the people own the means of production through their elected representatives (like India from Independence until the 80s). Of course if it fails, you're gonna cry "NoT rEaL SoCiAlIsM yOu ShItLiB"
What are your metrics for a successful economy? Vietnam, China and Cuba all seem to be doing just fine. Let’s check up on the US where unemployment is skyrocketing past Great Depression levels.
Are you brain-dead or something? The Coronavirus pandemic is causing people to file for unemployment. It will obviously take time for economies to restart once it's over.
Venezuela on the other hand tanked because of a little oil price fluctuation.
The oil economy here is also screwed lmao. Corporations are using this crisis to consolidate more monopolistic power and they’re going to find ways to fuck over worker’s protection during and after the pandemic. You’re an idealist pie-in-the-sky fool if you think there won’t be extremely negative longterm societal/economic repercussions of this. But of course the invisible hand saves all.
I never accused you of saying that, I'm saying Venezuela's economy got so fucking bad that Chavez and Maduro had to become authoritarians to stay in power. Maduro literally had to rig an election.
Vietnam and Cuba are doing fine, while Canada, the UK and the US are right on top of the mountain.
India was doing "fine" under democratic socialism too, but the liberalisation of the economy made it really grow. Liberalisation is also why China is a superpower.
That is why Marx literally said that communism can only be achieved in liberal industrialized countries but for some reason all the revolutions took place in colonial or feudal economies.
No communism had more appeal in countries where the economic divide was more stark, developed countries in the west negated any revolutionary potential because they created welfare nets that incentivized people to not go full revolutionary socialist. Which is ironic because the western liberal countries are the only ones with the technologically advanced productive forces to even be able to run a socialist economy. It’s a shit show.
your brand of capitalist bullshit is a nirvana fallacy. I hope you get lynched by a mob of unemployed people since the US is so perfect and handling COVID-19 so perfectly. I will be in that mob, neolib.
Looks like you're sending a lynch mob of strawmen right now cause you very well know that my 8-year old sister could kick your limp-wristed Chapo butt.
This is libel, and harassment - a civil tort, and a violation of the Reddit Content Policies.
The comment has been reported to Reddit administration. You have been banned from this subreddit. I reserve the right to sue you to reclaim damages to my reputation, and to pursue criminal charges against you. Reddit is likely to suspend your account.
This is libel, and harassment - a civil tort, and a violation of the Reddit Content Policies.
The comment has been reported to Reddit administration. You have been banned from this subreddit. I reserve the right to sue you to reclaim damages to my reputation, and to pursue criminal charges against you. Reddit is likely to suspend your account.
119 comments
1 AutoModerator 2020-04-30
do not comment or vote in linked threads
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
7 AltRitardando 2020-04-30
He'll feel differently once he starts to pay taxes 😂
5 qwertyashes 2020-04-30
Personally paying taxes is what drove me to the left. That those tax dollars are being distributed so poorly really pushed me to wish for reform and improvement.
I never really understood people that became libertarians over taxation at all, they were too dumb and naive to attract me.
1 [deleted] 2020-04-30
[removed]
1 AutoModerator 2020-04-30
Hi She-Daddy_Jenna!
This is libel, and harassment - a civil tort, and a violation of the Reddit Content Policies.
The comment has been reported to Reddit administration. You have been banned from this subreddit. I reserve the right to sue you to reclaim damages to my reputation, and to pursue criminal charges against you. Reddit is likely to suspend your account.
Goodbye.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
1 She-Daddy_Jenna 2020-04-30
Lmao, you are a buffoon.
4 petty_bourgeois_lib 2020-04-30
I do pay taxes you smug moron.
4 automatic_cluck 2020-04-30
This is libel, sweaty.
🙄🙄🙄
3 petty_bourgeois_lib 2020-04-30
oh no write me up
3 automatic_cluck 2020-04-30
...
2 byobombs 2020-04-30
Imagine paying “””taxes””” 🤢 just be self employed and lie on your taxes so you can reap those govment benefits AND not pay for it 😎😎😎
5 petty_bourgeois_lib 2020-04-30
Socialism is when you pay taxes and the more taxes you pay the more socialister society gets.
5 byobombs 2020-04-30
Socialick these nuts 😂🤣😘
4 petty_bourgeois_lib 2020-04-30
Wait who is the childish one again?
2 strallweat 2020-04-30
Hopefully not his nuts. Or else you'd be a libertarian.
1 Platycel 2020-04-30
unironically tho
1 petty_bourgeois_lib 2020-04-30
Ah yes Otto Von Bismarck was a socialist because he implemented welfare reform in Germany.
1 AltRitardando 2020-04-30
Son, I'm not talking about paying sales tax for a Nintendo game
1 petty_bourgeois_lib 2020-04-30
Wanna see my fucking tax return?
2 Lolbertians 2020-04-30
Include your SSN so we know it's you
1 petty_bourgeois_lib 2020-04-30
Sure its 69420911
3 mcbrd 2020-04-30
Bro you're a commie
2 petty_bourgeois_lib 2020-04-30
COMMIE MAN BAD
6 Lo_Fi_Liam 2020-04-30
communism is literally fantasy lol
4 petty_bourgeois_lib 2020-04-30
I could say the same about free-market Chicago school economics which constantly produces hot takes about how man is an island and society isn't real.
5 Lo_Fi_Liam 2020-04-30
i have no idea what any of that means
4 petty_bourgeois_lib 2020-04-30
Okay, then why are you arguing with me about political economy? Have you ever even read Marx? Probably not.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chicago_school_of_economics
5 Lo_Fi_Liam 2020-04-30
i don’t care about politics that have no existence in the modern world thanks 🤭
1 Mayos_side 2020-04-30
Neither do I but he's right.
1 Platycel 2020-04-30
Don't worry, neither does he.
1 aqouta 2020-04-30
Capitalism isn't a real thing.
1 petty_bourgeois_lib 2020-04-30
Damn you’re living in full socialism already?
1 aqouta 2020-04-30
I reject the idea that the the ability to own private property is the defining characteristic of an economy. It would be like defining modern cars as round wheel cars to differentiate them from the square wheel cars some crackpot claimed would be more efficient. It raises the silly idea of communism to a level where it can be compared to current real world economic systems despite never being able to exist for any real period of time.
1 petty_bourgeois_lib 2020-04-30
Private property and personal property are two different things. Personal property exists in communism. And no private property is not the defining characteristic of capitalism, the defining characteristic of capitalism is that it creates a society wherein all commodities are produced for value and not use. You should try reading some theory before you shit on entire branches of thought like a little baby.
2 aqouta 2020-04-30
I've read kapital, the criticism of what he called capitalism is fine, great at points but he does prescribe anything usable because he was a hegelian and thought his vision of communism was just inevitable in the way trade liberalization described by Smith seemed to be. He was wrong, just like he was wrong about phrenology.
1 petty_bourgeois_lib 2020-04-30
Yes nobody takes the determinist parts of Marx seriously. Its just as silly as Fukuyama declaring the end of history.
1 Fughtmeulilbitch 2020-04-30
Worked better than Karl Marx’s ideas tho 🤭 Imagine how ret@rded those must be
1 petty_bourgeois_lib 2020-04-30
Tell that to the Chileans.
1 Fughtmeulilbitch 2020-04-30
One of the countries with the highest living standards in South America? I’ll tell them 😎👍🏽
1 petty_bourgeois_lib 2020-04-30
"muh living standard CIA economik freedumb chart"
2 Fughtmeulilbitch 2020-04-30
Hey it’s not the CIA’s fault that you can’t comprehend charts.
1 petty_bourgeois_lib 2020-04-30
Yes it is.
1 srsh10392 2020-04-30
"muh Pinochet"
1 petty_bourgeois_lib 2020-04-30
Gimme that 70% below the poverty line neoliberal shock doctrine daddy
1 ridwan212 2020-04-30
CSE is a better school than you can get in so human nature wins again or something
1 petty_bourgeois_lib 2020-04-30
Hooman naytur
1 closedshop 2020-04-30
I’m curious, how did you reach these conclusions about the Chicago School? Furthermore, how much “mainstream” economics have you studied?
1 [deleted] 2020-04-30
I’ve studied about as much mainstream econ as you people have claimed to study marx.
1 closedshop 2020-04-30
I’m not sure what that means. If that means you have studied the basics of Economics, what attracted you to Marx’s theories? Do you subscribe to the labor theory of value?
4 She-Daddy_Jenna 2020-04-30
Yes.
2 TotesMessenger 2020-04-30
I'm a bot, bleep, bloop. Someone has linked to this thread from another place on reddit:
If you follow any of the above links, please respect the rules of reddit and don't vote in the other threads. (Info / Contact)
2 Commy_Mommy_Rises 2020-04-30
Unironically neoli🅱️eral is filled with some of the most smug retar*ds on earth and you're still making them look smart relative to you.
1 [deleted] 2020-04-30
[removed]
1 AutoModerator 2020-04-30
Hi petty_bourgeois_lib!
This is libel, and harassment - a civil tort, and a violation of the Reddit Content Policies.
The comment has been reported to Reddit administration. You have been banned from this subreddit. I reserve the right to sue you to reclaim damages to my reputation, and to pursue criminal charges against you. Reddit is likely to suspend your account.
Goodbye.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
1 [deleted] 2020-04-30
[removed]
1 Can_The_SRDine 2020-04-30
The communist is immunized against all dangers. One may call him a layabout, parasite, ignoramus, NEET, it all runs off him like water off a raincoat. But call him a manchild and you will be astonished at how he recoils, how injured he is, how he shrinks back: “I’ve been found out!”
3 petty_bourgeois_lib 2020-04-30
My ideology is only for GOOD smart adult white-collar wageslaves, your ideology BAD because poor people dumb and Venezuela!
7 automatic_cluck 2020-04-30
Tankie engine go vroom vroom
1 petty_bourgeois_lib 2020-04-30
"Everybody who is anti-capitalist is a Stalinist"- An emotional neoliberal's guide to the left
2 automatic_cluck 2020-04-30
...
5 McFluff_TheCrimeCat 2020-04-30
Do you think people aren’t basically wage slaves under communists regimes? Do you think they let people just not work? And it’s bad since it doesn’t work on large scales until a more technologically advanced society can sustain it but that’s another matter from your silly Venezuela poor people straw man.
4 petty_bourgeois_lib 2020-04-30
I have no illusions about shitty state-capitalist countries but if you think that your neoliberal capitalist countries somehow produce any less suffering you're a fool.
6 newcomer_ts 2020-04-30
We all at /r/drama are suffering a fool rn
Because this month, we are merciful.
Go on... let it all out...
3 petty_bourgeois_lib 2020-04-30
I'm suffering your mom right now.
4 newcomer_ts 2020-04-30
At least this thread has unironic title.
Look, commie... you couldn't smooth a silk sheet if you had a hot date with a babe... I lost my train of thought, can you nationalize it?
3 petty_bourgeois_lib 2020-04-30
look neolib we all know that daddy paid for your econ classes and now you think you're a big boy, gonna throw me out of a helicopter in Chile now?
1 newcomer_ts 2020-04-30
I can throw movie references as anyone...
1 petty_bourgeois_lib 2020-04-30
If r/neoliberal was a movie it would be Brazil.
1 newcomer_ts 2020-04-30
If r/etard was a sub you'd be a mod
1 petty_bourgeois_lib 2020-04-30
I’m flattered
1 She-Daddy_Jenna 2020-04-30
Except for how much less suffering there is, by every conceivable measure, lol.
1 petty_bourgeois_lib 2020-04-30
Aight dude let's ship you off to a lithium mine in Bolivia and we'll see how much you love capitalism then.
1 She-Daddy_Jenna 2020-04-30
I live in a capitalist country and I'm not being shipped to a Bolivian lithium mine, so I'm not really sure what you're getting at.
1 petty_bourgeois_lib 2020-04-30
"my middle-class suburban existence is free of woe so capitalism must be great for everybody down the supply chain"
1 srsh10392 2020-04-30
Alright dude let's ship you off to Venezuela and we'll see how much you love socialism then.
1 petty_bourgeois_lib 2020-04-30
Venezuela has a market economy you mong they are socialist in name only. Just like how the US is free market in name only.
1 srsh10392 2020-04-30
ItS nOt ReAl SoCIaLiSM
1 petty_bourgeois_lib 2020-04-30
Yes and?
1 petty_bourgeois_lib 2020-04-30
Socialism is when state own thing and say socialism!
1 srsh10392 2020-04-30
A completely nationalised economy in a representative democracy could be considered a form of democratic socialism, since the people own the means of production through their elected representatives (like India from Independence until the 80s). Of course if it fails, you're gonna cry "NoT rEaL SoCiAlIsM yOu ShItLiB"
1 petty_bourgeois_lib 2020-04-30
Imagine thinking representative democracy is worker’s direct control of the means of production.
1 srsh10392 2020-04-30
Then what is? How do you suggest the workers take control of the means of production?
1 petty_bourgeois_lib 2020-04-30
Through worker’s councils and syndicates wherein workers in a given field figure out what needs to be produced.
1 srsh10392 2020-04-30
Oh no, is r-slurred.
1 petty_bourgeois_lib 2020-04-30
lmao he thinks modern consumer capitalism doesn’t involve state intervention.
0 srsh10392 2020-04-30
Never said that you brainlet, state-capitalism is the stupid copout you use when someone points to a failed socialist state.
0 petty_bourgeois_lib 2020-04-30
I forgot only socialist states fail and market economies are perfect.
1 srsh10392 2020-04-30
No, you forgot that socialist states fail like 99% of the time, while every successful economy is capitalist.
1 petty_bourgeois_lib 2020-04-30
What are your metrics for a successful economy? Vietnam, China and Cuba all seem to be doing just fine. Let’s check up on the US where unemployment is skyrocketing past Great Depression levels.
1 srsh10392 2020-04-30
Wait, suddenly China is socialist?
1 petty_bourgeois_lib 2020-04-30
By your definition they are.
1 srsh10392 2020-04-30
I never said "state intervention = socialism"
1 srsh10392 2020-04-30
What is the Coronavirus pandemic?
1 petty_bourgeois_lib 2020-04-30
Its cute how you think everything will go back to normal once the pandemic is over.
1 srsh10392 2020-04-30
Are you brain-dead or something? The Coronavirus pandemic is causing people to file for unemployment. It will obviously take time for economies to restart once it's over.
Venezuela on the other hand tanked because of a little oil price fluctuation.
1 petty_bourgeois_lib 2020-04-30
The oil economy here is also screwed lmao. Corporations are using this crisis to consolidate more monopolistic power and they’re going to find ways to fuck over worker’s protection during and after the pandemic. You’re an idealist pie-in-the-sky fool if you think there won’t be extremely negative longterm societal/economic repercussions of this. But of course the invisible hand saves all.
1 srsh10392 2020-04-30
First off, I'm not a burger. Second, last I checked, the US was much better off, and, uh, not a dictatorship.
0 petty_bourgeois_lib 2020-04-30
When did I ever call the US a dictatorship? Fuck off europoor.
1 srsh10392 2020-04-30
I never accused you of saying that, I'm saying Venezuela's economy got so fucking bad that Chavez and Maduro had to become authoritarians to stay in power. Maduro literally had to rig an election.
1 petty_bourgeois_lib 2020-04-30
Yes Maduro is incompetent most socialists that aren’t plugged into the RT shitfest would agree.
1 srsh10392 2020-04-30
Vietnam and Cuba are doing fine, while Canada, the UK and the US are right on top of the mountain.
India was doing "fine" under democratic socialism too, but the liberalisation of the economy made it really grow. Liberalisation is also why China is a superpower.
1 petty_bourgeois_lib 2020-04-30
That is why Marx literally said that communism can only be achieved in liberal industrialized countries but for some reason all the revolutions took place in colonial or feudal economies.
1 srsh10392 2020-04-30
So commies are dumb?
1 petty_bourgeois_lib 2020-04-30
No communism had more appeal in countries where the economic divide was more stark, developed countries in the west negated any revolutionary potential because they created welfare nets that incentivized people to not go full revolutionary socialist. Which is ironic because the western liberal countries are the only ones with the technologically advanced productive forces to even be able to run a socialist economy. It’s a shit show.
1 srsh10392 2020-04-30
Classic case of the Nirvana fallacy
1 petty_bourgeois_lib 2020-04-30
Also Marx was not a utopian lol.
1 srsh10392 2020-04-30
The Nirvana fallacy here is thinking socialism would be superior because capitalism is performing unsatisfactorily.
0 petty_bourgeois_lib 2020-04-30
your brand of capitalist bullshit is a nirvana fallacy. I hope you get lynched by a mob of unemployed people since the US is so perfect and handling COVID-19 so perfectly. I will be in that mob, neolib.
1 srsh10392 2020-04-30
Looks like you're sending a lynch mob of strawmen right now cause you very well know that my 8-year old sister could kick your limp-wristed Chapo butt.
1 [deleted] 2020-04-30
I don’t even post on chapo you libcuck
1 [deleted] 2020-04-30
[deleted]
1 [deleted] 2020-04-30
[removed]
2 AutoModerator 2020-04-30
Hi Kat_B0T!
This is libel, and harassment - a civil tort, and a violation of the Reddit Content Policies.
The comment has been reported to Reddit administration. You have been banned from this subreddit. I reserve the right to sue you to reclaim damages to my reputation, and to pursue criminal charges against you. Reddit is likely to suspend your account.
Goodbye.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
3 automatic_cluck 2020-04-30
Sad!
1 [deleted] 2020-04-30
[removed]
1 AutoModerator 2020-04-30
Hi ESL-ASMR!
This is libel, and harassment - a civil tort, and a violation of the Reddit Content Policies.
The comment has been reported to Reddit administration. You have been banned from this subreddit. I reserve the right to sue you to reclaim damages to my reputation, and to pursue criminal charges against you. Reddit is likely to suspend your account.
Goodbye.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
1 ESL-ASMR 2020-04-30
Oh no
1 bkad29 2020-04-30
God I love this sub.