Here we spot wild Bardfinn Bluesky activities.
Be valid and ping ! bardfinn for something worthwhile or create a new thread.
Here we spot wild Bardfinn Bluesky activities.
Be valid and ping ! bardfinn for something worthwhile or create a new thread.
Jump in the discussion.
No email address required.
Ms. Penny ๐ ๐งโ๏ธ Oaken (@skywitches.net):
For the people who want the details:
I'm Penny Oaken; I have helped run /r/AgainstHateSubreddits since 2019. In 2020 we succeeded in getting Reddit to adopt a sitewide policy against hate speech, banning 4,000+ subreddits & 40,000+ user accounts in 2020.
Ms. Penny ๐ ๐งโ๏ธ Oaken (@skywitches.net):
We also pushed hard for a Moderator Code of Conduct that holds subreddit operators responsible for the uses their subreddits are put to by users.
In the past 365 days, Reddit has banned
200 subreddits as hate subreddits,100 june-December 2023, ~100 January-June 2024.Ms. Penny ๐ ๐งโ๏ธ Oaken (@skywitches.net):
That's the stable long tail โ AHS & Reddit's policy against hate speech are proof that social media can counter & prevent hate speech, and preventing hate speech has an effect of reducing violent organization & harassment.
That makes AHS the most successful protest movement ever on Reddit.
Ms. Penny ๐ ๐งโ๏ธ Oaken (@skywitches.net):
Lots of lessons learned along the way include :
Denying hate groups & trolls the Oxygen of Amplification
datasociety.net/library/oxyg...
BlueSky's "Nuclear Block" feature works for this purpose.
We don't dunk on or entertain bigots. They get their fuel supply choked off by the block.
Ms. Penny ๐ ๐งโ๏ธ Oaken (@skywitches.net):
My specific field of expertise is White Identity Extremism- i.e., neoNazis. For years before I joined AHS, I infiltrated neonazi groups on Reddit - sometimes by long, hard work, and sometimes by sheer luck.
Ms. Penny ๐ ๐งโ๏ธ Oaken (@skywitches.net):
I discovered (by luck) in 2017 that the people running /r/The_Donald were conspiring with the people running /r/CringeAnarchy, /r/MetaCanada, and many other hate groups on Reddit to harass anti-racist subreddit moderators off the platform.
The takeaway there is that /r/The_Donald was run by neoNazis
Ms. Penny ๐ ๐งโ๏ธ Oaken (@skywitches.net):
The people running /r/the_donald, CringeAnarchy, etc were also setting up and promoting Unite The Right in Charlottesville, were hosting ISIS propaganda videos & the Christchurch shooter's vid on /r/WatchPeopleDie, etc
They're Domestic Violent Extremists
Ms. Penny ๐ ๐งโ๏ธ Oaken (@skywitches.net):
So along the way I've also picked up the White House Strategy for Countering Domestic Terrorism
www.whitehouse.gov/wp-content/u...
Ms. Penny ๐ ๐งโ๏ธ Oaken (@skywitches.net):
And the final entry to this thread, the methodology I use to qualify my blocklists -
The Abusive Language Occurrences Ontology from Zeinert et al., (2021)
www.derczynski.com/papers/annot...
Ms. Penny ๐ ๐งโ๏ธ Oaken (@skywitches.net):
The ontology boils down to
is the speech abusive
is the abusive speech targeting someone (else)
is the abusive speech targeting someone else for abuse based on that target's group / inherent or perceived identity or demography
Ms. Penny ๐ ๐งโ๏ธ Oaken (@skywitches.net):
At least one of my blocklists, Carnival Barkers, is premised on the broadest possible reading of this ontology, and inspired by the real Twitter example of Boogie2988, who refused basic virtual hygiene and so had the effect of focusing 3rd party harassment on anyone he engaged with
Ms. Penny ๐ ๐งโ๏ธ Oaken (@skywitches.net):
You should probably not subscribe to Carnival Barkers. The rest of the lists are well characterised and their ontologies proven by time and effect)
Ms. Penny ๐ ๐งโ๏ธ Oaken (@skywitches.net):
Don't want to see Bitcoin or cryptocurrency hawkers / promoters? Neither do I.
bsky.app/profile/did:...
Ms. Penny ๐ ๐งโ๏ธ Oaken (@skywitches.net):
Don't want to see astroturfing sockpuppets, block evaders, people who violate boundaries and can't respect "No"? Neither do I
bsky.app/profile/did:...
Ms. Penny ๐ ๐งโ๏ธ Oaken (@skywitches.net):
Sometimes Nazis & White Identity Extremists slip past BlueSky Trust & Safety. We don't wonder "Why?", we just report them and throw them on the blocklists
bsky.app/profile/did:...
Ms. Penny ๐ ๐งโ๏ธ Oaken (@skywitches.net):
People who circumvent blocks? People who can't take the hint? People who feel entitled to a captive audience?
I don't like them. No one is entitled to your time and attention.
bsky.app/profile/did:...
Ms. Penny ๐ ๐งโ๏ธ Oaken (@skywitches.net):
People who patronise the targets / victims of hateful oppression and bigotry? The folks who like to tell protestors against genocide to shut up?
Don't like 'em.
bsky.app/profile/did:...
Ms. Penny ๐ ๐งโ๏ธ Oaken (@skywitches.net):
The rest of the lists are specific evils worth blocking by everyone, but members of certain groups will immediately recognise the names or parameters. They're not worth diving into.
Ms. Penny ๐ ๐งโ๏ธ Oaken (@skywitches.net):
HERE IS THE AWESOME PART
Anyone can make a blocklist
And the decentralised aspect means that layered moderation here is immune to government / billionaires / hackers leveraging power or privilege to shut it down
Ms. Penny ๐ ๐งโ๏ธ Oaken (@skywitches.net):
If one person's account & their blocklists falls, if one hosting server falls, it doesn't break things for everyone else
Jump in the discussion.
No email address required.
Ms. Penny ๐ ๐งโ๏ธ Oaken (@skywitches.net):
aclanthology.org/2021.acl-lon...
Alternate host for Zeinert et al (2011) since the link above is 403
Jump in the discussion.
No email address required.
More options
Context
More options
Context