Unable to load image

History books discussion thread :marmseylegionnaire::marseypharaoh::marseycrusader:

So you guys can discuss and recommend history book of any kind. This is also the type of book I read most over the years so here’s my recommendation list

On Ancient Mesopotamia

Babylon: Mesopotamia and the Birth of Civilization (Paul Kriwaczek)

On Ancient Egypt

The rise and fall of ancient Egypt (Toby Wilkinson)

On Ancient Greece

The Spartans (Paul Cartledge)

Rise of Athens (Anthony Everitt)

Alexander the Great (Paul Cartledge)

Alexander the Great (Philip Freeman)

On Ancient Rome

The Storm before the Storm (Mike Duncan) WARNING: Duncan is not an historian and his books are just a collection of primary sources with his opinions on them, so take this with a grain of salt”

SPQR (Mary Beard)

Augustus (Adrian Goldsworthy)

How Rome fell: Fall of a Superpower (Adrian Goldsworthy)

The Fall of Rome (Bryan Ward Perkins)

On the Byzantines

Byzantium: The surprising life of a medieval empire (Judith Herrin)

On the Baltics

The northern crusaders (Eric Christianssen)

On the Middle East

Jerusalem a Biography (Simon Sebag Montefiore)

The Arabs (Eugene Rogan)

The House of Wisdom (Jimal Khalili)

On precolumbian Americas

The Maya (Michael d Coe)

1491 (Charles Mann)

1493 (Charles Mann)

On the Portuguese Empire

Conquerors (Roger Crowley)

On Caribbean Slavery

Mastery Tyranny and desire (Trevor Burnard)

The Plantation Machine (Trevor Burnard)

Colonial America

The Island at the center of the world (Russell Shorto)

Colonial Africa

King Leopold’s Ghost (Adam Hochschild)

On American slavery

The fall of the House of Dixie (Bruce Levine)

Empire of Cotton (Sven Beckert)

On Imperial Russia

The Romanovs (Simon Sebag Montefiore)

On WW1

The Great War (Peter Hart)

On the Nazi economy

The Wages of Destruction (Adam Tooze)

15
Jump in the discussion.

No email address required.

One soldiers War about the Chechnya wars

The Crucible of War about the seven years war

The Franco Prussian War, this one is obvious

Storm of Steel about WWI from a German soldiers view

Rubicon

Crusading Warfare 1097-1193

I've read loads of others but these are semi recent. Of the list my favorites would be Storm of Steel and One Soldiers War. All of them are good, The Crucible of War is a tome though. Things massive and I've been working through it forever. Really enjoyable to read but one where you can kinda zone out and end up needing to go back and re-read a page.

Crusading Warfare is the most academic of the bunch. It's something I read for a project I haven't finished, but I did enjoy it. Just a bit dry

Jump in the discussion.

No email address required.

My understanding is that the Charles Mann books have a mediocre reputation among other American historians

Jump in the discussion.

No email address required.

Charles Mann is not an historian, he’s a journ*list and 1491 for instance is a collection of several archeological findings, primary sources of European chronists and DNA studies of precolumbian America to paint a general picture. It’s pop history, not a textbook, but pop history of quality still, unlike Harari’s “Sapiens”.

Michael Doe on the other hand is a respected mayanist, and he authored several high quality textbooks. He’s the type of author you should look into if you’re interested in more serious analysis. Still couldn’t find an author like him for the aztecs and the Inca.

That said, I still think Mann is worth reading, I learned a lot about the Amazon forest and how Indians artificially modified entire landscapes that today we take as “natural”. So even if some of the book’s research is now dated or if some of Mann personal takes are wrong, it can still tell you about things you didn't know you “didn’t know”, and leave you with a desire to learn more about from other sources.

Jump in the discussion.

No email address required.

Actually 2 good history books

  • coming out under fire

  • the world turned rightside up

Both happen to be about homos

:#marseysmug2:

Jump in the discussion.

No email address required.

The Spanish Labyrinth by Gerald Brenan

Jump in the discussion.

No email address required.

The enemy at the gate- about the siege of Vienna is Fantastic

Hymns of the republic

Destiny of the republic

Jump in the discussion.

No email address required.

:#chainedkong:

Jump in the discussion.

No email address required.

Link copied to clipboard
Action successful!
Error, please refresh the page and try again.