https://x.com/lbc/status/1737015437966086404
'There are no churches in Gaza…’
— LBC (@LBC) December 19, 2023
Deputy Mayor of Jerusalem Fleur Hassan-Nahoum responds to reports the IDF have targeted a Catholic Church in Gaza. pic.twitter.com/8yuyzUnAoy
Church? There are no Churches in Gaza so I don't know where the report is talking about” “There are no Christians in Gaza….”. “Well I don't know… I didn't see the report, I don't know”.
https://x.com/BaderRifat/status/1736837819589410891
Reminder to all you that they'd be happy to kill you too if you ever left the gooncave in your parent's basement.
Jump in the discussion.
No email address required.
Also, if Christians had maintained your high "moral" standards, there would be no Christianity today. Which now that they've become less Christian, ironically they actually do sort of maintain these standards and now soon enough Europe might be Muslim.
Jump in the discussion.
No email address required.
Christianity wins by subverting societies, not conquering them. We're supposed to work like people think the Jews do.
Prior to the modern state of Israel, Jews survived almost 2000 years without ever being a majority or wielding state power, and they don't even proselytize. I think we'd have survived.
Jump in the discussion.
No email address required.
Yeah, you'd have "survived" like the Middle Eastern Christians of today. Were you very successful at subverting those societies or did you spend one and a half millennia being massacred, r*ped and extorted while dwindling from a n overwhelming majority to a tiny minority?
Jump in the discussion.
No email address required.
Christianity obviously did not come to prominence in the Roman Empire by violently conquering it, and current historiography emphasizes the bottom-up aspect of its growth (ie. it did not "win" just because of a few converts who forced it on the masses by state power; growth rates were broadly stable over time).
The difficulties came after: can you remain just and righteous after "winning"? History suggests this is much harder.
Jump in the discussion.
No email address required.
Christianity won against a decentralized "religion" in serious decline long before Christianity even existed. The Hellenistic world was in a serious crisis of faith and doesn't demand exclusivity, so Christianity could spread gradually through syncretism. And even then in some regions of the empire it only won by force. (Chiefly against the Jews and Samaritans.) Against modern monotheistic religions it doesn't have a good track record of success.
Jump in the discussion.
No email address required.
Christianity's primary global competitor today is not Islam, but atheism or apathy. For a modern model of Christian growth, we can look to the church in China. I've had the fortune of meeting some Chinese Christians from outside the state's "approved" system. There's real energy there. I feel hopeful for the coming decades and centuries. It's good for the spiritual center of the church to move from time to time, and I accept that it's moving out of the West.
The West, meanwhile, is becoming a spiritually empty space. The question here is different. Can Christianity slowly convert a society that was once Christian but appeared to move "past" it? I think it's possible, but it can't come from the extant institutional churches. We can't be constantly chasing secular liberal trends, but we also can't be a performative larp for reactionary chuds. We need to be a primary source of meaning, not an auxiliary for some other cause. A turnaround can only take place over the arc of history. I hope that in my life we will begin to see it.
Jump in the discussion.
No email address required.
I disagree, since atheism and apathy don't have a mission to conquer and subjugate Christianity. Right now, Christians are too powerful to be threatened by Muslims but in three generations when Muslims are the majority in France and Germany, they will be on the receiving end once again, together with atheists.
The "meaning" of Christianity has always been adapted to the society and social order it found itself in or at least the society that was exporting it, so wouldn't the choice of which be arbitrary? Do you adopt an evangelical, Episcopalian, Maronite, Ethiopian Orthodox or Japanese Catholic value system to give you meaning? They're all very different obviously. Clearly you need to wed it to some compatible contemporary value system.
Jump in the discussion.
No email address required.
Muslim growth seems like a special fixation of secularists scared to discover they're not really the end of history. The thought of a largely Muslim Europe in 2070 causes far less trouble for my worldview then the thought of a largely atheist Europe in 2070. If God is real, I should expect atheism to be a transient period of spiritual vacuity, not an incidental part of a successful, complete liberal rationalist ideology that can sustain itself forever. The latter would be a real threat, in a way that "another faith has temporarily become more popular than mine" could never be.
The majority of Muslims worldwide are not in anachronistic sandshit tribes or tinpot theocracies. I'm not pretending it's always peaceful, but it doesn't look like the neocon caricature either. There are also examples of Christian growth in majority Muslim environments like Indonesia.
Jump in the discussion.
No email address required.
No, it's genuinely terrifying to see backwards supremacist savages become the majority. It's basic self preservation. I wouldn't mind and would in fact prefer a more Christian Western world.
Why in particular atheism? Surely this logic applies to every wrong religion?
No but even the ones that aren't are backwards shitholes that oppress religious and ethnic minorities. Let's take a look where officially (never mind unofficial persecution) the death penalty for leaving Islam is in effect:
Don't forget of course that the Muslim world is constantly in flux so yesterday's monarchy or military dictatorship is today's theocratic dictatorship.
Now let's look at the worst places in the world to be a Christian:
https://www.christianitytoday.com/news/2021/january/christian-persecution-2021-countries-open-doors-watch-list.html
Do you see a pattern?
Your one example is where Christianity is a prestige religion because of its association with the wealthy West. So this route is also out the window if you leave Europe to the Muslims.
Jump in the discussion.
No email address required.
More options
Context
More options
Context
More options
Context
More options
Context
More options
Context
More options
Context
More options
Context
More options
Context
More options
Context