emoji-award-marseyretardcheers
Unable to load image

lain's :marseylain: Basic and Bulletproof Old Fashioned cocktail :marseycheers:

Hello !boozers

Here's a very basic old fashioned recipe. If your reaction is "this is literally a basic old fashion" - you are correct. :marseyagree:

During my experimentation these are the core ingredients and steps required to make a good Old Fashioned. :marseybountyhunter:

By following these steps to a T I believe you will end up with a better old fashion than most bars. :marseythumbsup:

Ingredients

1.) Whiskey Glass - Having a basic "rocks" glass is a decent idea, it's more trendy to have "tulip" style but a "rocks" glass is the traditional choice.

2.) Ice Mold - I have found ice molds are totally worth it. The interplay of the ice and spirit is key in an Old Fashion and the molds let the ice melt at a slower, more consistent rate.

3.) Metal Toothpick - Very nice to work with vs wood or whatever. Cleans easy, cheap and looks way better.

4.) Measuring Device - I am personally using a small jigger, knowing how much your measuring device holds is essential.

5.) Peeler / Good knife skills - We'll use this to get the top of the rind of the orange.

6.) Fresh Orange - We will be using the oils in the skin.

7.) Bitters - A bottle of proper Angostura Bitters will last you forever, this is what we'll be using in this recipe.

8.) Luxardo Cherries - These SoBs are expensive but 100% worth it. You should need to use one or two per drink so they do last.

9.) Simple Syrup - Simple Syrup is literally sugar water. Very old recipes would call for sugar cubes and grinding them into the drink but this is silly. You can make this yourself buy boiling 1 part water and then adding 1 part sugar (i.e. 1 cup sugar to 1 cup boiling water). Put it in a recycled bottle and top with vodka to store for months.

10.) Spirit - I will be using Bourbon Whiskey but you can be pretty creative with this. I basically recommend any aged base spirit (Whiskey, Bourbon, Rye Whiskey, Scotch Whisky, Brandy, Aged Rum, Cognac, etc). The sweetness of your spirit is what you'll use to gauge the syrup amount.

Steps

1.) Add ice to your glass.

https://i.rdrama.net/images/17018374604781027.webp

2.) Measure 90ml of your spirit. A usual pour is 60ml but rocks drinks are conventionally 1.5x.

https://i.rdrama.net/images/17018374608142433.webp

https://i.rdrama.net/images/17018374611329982.webp

3.) Add a splash of simple syrup. this ranges from 10ml-20ml, depending on your spirits sweetness. I usually do 15ml on unfamiliar bottles and then adjust from there.

https://i.rdrama.net/images/17018374614785964.webp

4.) Add three dashes of bitters. Stir.

https://i.rdrama.net/images/17018374617869828.webp

5.) Stab your cherry and fight with it until you make it in the glass

https://i.rdrama.net/images/1701837462183639.webp

https://i.rdrama.net/images/17018374624869816.webp

6.) Cut off a very thin slice of only the top of the orange rind. That's where all the orange oil is.

https://i.rdrama.net/images/17018374628035502.webp

7.) Fold the rind just-so above your drink so, if you look closely you'll see the oil spray across the glass. I can get a solid two spritzes out of a cut. Drop it into the drink after.

https://i.rdrama.net/images/17018374631502464.webp

8.) Enjoy!

https://i.rdrama.net/images/17018374635203996.webp

65
Jump in the discussion.

No email address required.

If you're going to be posting cocktails im gonna have to start posting some actual recipes, probably around friday so people who go out can try to order one at a bar.

Jump in the discussion.

No email address required.

Any recommendations on where to start for bitters beyond angostura? I usually drink my whiskey neat.

My favorite readily available bourbon is probably Four Roses Small Batch Select. Favorite Old Fashioned I've ever had was at the Parker Beam memorial breakfast a few years ago where they were serving Old Fashioneds with Parker's Heritage Heavy Char Rye.

Jump in the discussion.

No email address required.

Bitter Truth is a great start, they have a massive range to go from and their Jerry Thomas' Own Bitters is their take on an "angostura" done with more complexity. Fee brothers has a few interesting ones, their Xocolatl bitters are very cacao and cinnamon forward which pair amazingly with an orange twist garnish. Tiki bitters are super good, theres a bar I recommended to @FrozenXorg that has an old fashioned with tiki bitters and brown sugar syrup.

Orange bitters is classic, my recommendation being Regans as it actually tastes like orange (unlike angostura orange).

Jump in the discussion.

No email address required.

I added Regan's and tiki from Bittermens to my cart - I didn't realize you could buy these from Amazon :marseybrainlet:

Is there a third one from that list that's essential.

Jump in the discussion.

No email address required.

Bitters autism is one of the best autisms to get. You wanna grab them based on what you tend to drink. For example, if you make a honey collins often (great during summer) then lavender bitters are a great investment because they really shine with a floral honey sipper. Read the descriptions and see if what they say is in there pairs well with the notes of your favorite bottles. You can also mix bitters together so instead of 2 dashes of angostura you can do 1 orange and 1 fee bros xocolatl to add an orange chocolate vibe to a drink (works super well with a chocolate negroni)

Jump in the discussion.

No email address required.

Is there one you'd recommend for cognac and one for rum?

Jump in the discussion.

No email address required.

Bittermens tiki bitters say theyre cinammon and allspice forward with a lot of supporting background flavors. Cinammon and allspice could work well with a highly molasses forward rum like a Barbados or Trinidad style rum, not so much Jamaica since it steals from the banana funk. Their Transatlantic Bitters may also be worth considering for cognac and Rye. Literally just read the descriptions of the flavor profile and think of how well it pairs with the flavor profiles of bottles you already drink: https://www.bittermens.com/products/transatlantic

For cognac id recommend Jerry Thomas' Own Bitters by Bitter truth if you steep like half a bottle in black tea leaves for a few hours. I told you before, the autism between specific bottle and bitters is where it really shines. Bitterschads can elevate drinks better than many ingredients can so a bar with lots of different bitters should stand out as above average.

Jump in the discussion.

No email address required.

if you can find Mellow Corn that'll put hair on your chest.

Jump in the discussion.

No email address required.

I've tried orange bitters before, which were nice in old fashioned.

Maybe try Peychaud's bitters, they are more minty and are also used for cocktails like Sazerac?

Jump in the discussion.

No email address required.

Please do.

I have no clue where I'd find a competent bar tender though

Jump in the discussion.

No email address required.

You sorta doxed yourself a year back in pms asking me about mezcal. I can find out for you if you can confirm that you live in the spot i think you're at.

Jump in the discussion.

No email address required.

i love doxxing myself :marseywholesome:

Jump in the discussion.

No email address required.

Cant believe you actually admitted to living in new jersey but not anywhere close to NYC, absolutely over for your Michigan butt, like how the frick can you tolerate living in Seattle?

Jokes aside you'd better stop at that fricking bar I recommended for you and tell me if their old fashioned was worth the trip (it fricking should be given that ingredient list)

Jump in the discussion.

No email address required.

Link copied to clipboard
Action successful!
Error, please refresh the page and try again.