What are your favorite books?

Maybe try another McCarthy book if you liked his style, No Country for Old Men perhaps?

Coin Locker Babies and The Wind-Up Bird Chronicle are both pretty excellent and (relatively) unknown novels in the English world I think, if you're looking for heady, meaty fiction.

Evola is compelling, even if his philosophy isn't your jam, but he's generally a bit of a difficult read. Also like super moid so I'm not sure I'd recommend that after all. You're young, it's a good idea to get familiar with Dostoevsky's works because for whatever reason Russian classics seem to both impress people and get you looked down on if you've not read them. Give Dostoevsky a try.

In Search Of Lost Time is also, inexplicably, considered the greatest work of fiction by many for some reason? I think it's just the most boring thing ever written, but it's also important to have read just for the sake of having read it. Many things are like that and it's good to read them for the sake of optics and discussion. Pick up a nice Proust set and get suffering.

The Brothers Karamazov is sublime

Whatever you think is a must-read book!

There's a book called How to Read a Book by Mortimer J. Adler and Charles Van Doren. Give it a read. Some of the advice is a bit dated, but most of it is timeless.

When you finish, there's an appendix at the end with a "recommended reading" list. Read everything ever written by every author listed. If they mention something you don't understand, make a note of it and look it up. If they mention another author, or if you find another author mentioned in your research, read their work as well.

By the time you've made it to the bottom of the list, you'll be at the starting point of what I would consider "well read". You'll also have received a better education than 90% of college graduates.

Oh, one more thing. The biggest weakness of Adler and Van Doren's list is that it's very Eurocentric, so be sure to read some works outside the Western canon as well.