Unable to load image
Reported by:
  • JimothyX5 : Stupid, unfunny and completely unrelated to drama

:marseynerd: Am I an acceptable poster for theMotte.org? [-17 votes, 34 replies]

https://www.themotte.org/post/310/am-i-an-acceptable-poster-for

Hi, I'm a long time reader of Slate Star Codex and I used to post on the Reddit forum until I got banned. There are a few reasons that I believe I got banned.

  1. Uncharitably claiming that Leftist censorship was a threat to the rationalist community

  2. Advocating for violence

  3. Not being kind

I understand why all of these things could have been a problem on the Reddit community, but I would like to know if they're still going to be a problem here, since I don't want to invest a lot of time creating a profile and having good-faith discussions with people if I'm only going to be banned again. Here are the reasons that I think these three issues shouldn't be a problem anymore.

  1. I was right, and everybody who disagreed with me was wrong. The fact that the community had to move here proves it. I'm not expecting an apology but I think that time has proven me correct on that score.

  2. Violence is a completely justifiable response to tyranny. While calls to violence may be against Reddit rules (and the community was right to ban me from Reddit because my rhetoric could have caused problems for the mods) there are no such rules here. In fact, rdrama (which helped set up this offsite community, and whom you should all be grateful to) actively encourages calls to violence. If a rational and logical case can be made for violence then I think there is no good reason not to hear that case out. If you're forced to censor people you disagree with because you're unable to make a stronger case for pacifism over violence in the open marketplace of ideas, then you should question whether your pacifism is actually a worthwhile philosophy.

  3. Kindness and truth are different terminal values. If you optimize for kindness then it is self-evident that you will have to sacrifice truth at some point. Obviously the Reddit community has chosen kindness as its terminal value, but I'm hoping that this offsite community is enlightened enough to choose truth.

I'm linking to a few articles from my Substack here so you have a few examples of my style of writing and can make a better judgement about whether I would be a good fit for the offsite community. I'm also on rdrama where my username is sirpingsalot. If you think I'm not a good fit for the offsite either, then no hard feelings - I'm happy to take my ideas to more sympathetic communities instead. I just don't want to put in the effort of investing time and energy here if I'm only going to get banned again for the same reasons.

70
Jump in the discussion.

No email address required.

Even their site is painfully dull

Jump in the discussion.

No email address required.

What a bunch of cute twinks. Realizing humans simply aren't equipped to have rational, serious discussions is the most enlightened position. I don't want to hear chumps moralizing about imbecilities. Do something a human is good at, like be cruel to your friend behind his back, or talk about how ugly people are.

:#marseybigbrain:

Jump in the discussion.

No email address required.

I just cant understand people who take the internet seriously.

Jump in the discussion.

No email address required.

They're basically fairly-smart neurodivergents who don't get any respect from normies. But instead of saying "normies suck" and forcing the normies to respect them by disrupting the status quo (which they could easily do with a little coordination), they constantly try to win normie approval by behaving "respectfully" and "appropriately." The normies will never respect rationalists until the rationalists put their boots on the throats of some people in power and gently press down. The rationalist delusion that they can win the respect of society by being nice and playing by society's rules is as moronic as the Swifty delusion that if they simp hard enough for Taylor Swift on Reddit, she'll put out for them. Honestly I respect the Swifty delusion more because at least they get some good music out of it

Jump in the discussion.

No email address required.

Grim

Bleak

I don't like it and I choose not to believe it; we should optimize the human race for the perfect mix of kindness and autism

Jump in the discussion.

No email address required.

Link copied to clipboard
Action successful!
Error, please refresh the page and try again.