I read a 126 page PDF of one of the most recommended r/nosleep stories and the entire thing ended up being completely not scary and the only purpose was to build up to the last few pages where the narrator learned that just because she doesn’t say “no” doesn’t mean it’s not r*pe, from his (“Yiddish”) therapist

That’s it. That’s all. That’s literally the entire purpose of the story. To make a point about enthusiastic consent.

It’s The Spire in the Woods, if you’re wondering. I needed to find a PDF because it got turned into a book and I’m not paying to read fricking Reddit posts. It’s absolutely not worth your time.

74
Jump in the discussion.

No email address required.

The real problem is that it's original idea of "scary stories but they're being told as if they actually happened" was forgotten as far as the actual writing is concerned. You can still see its legacy in the comments IIRC, with every r-slur LARPing it out like the above story was a totes true account. Once the sub forgot about that rule it just devolved into half assed fanfiction tier shit and "wholesome" horror (the latter of which makes me sneed hard).

Jump in the discussion.

No email address required.

I disagree. The "larp as a true story" rule made it so that every story had the protagonist escape and make it back to civilization so they can write a post on reddit, or told through someone else's found notes and stuff. Really limiting, especially on how you can end a story.

Jump in the discussion.

No email address required.

Yeah. But at the same time the few remarkable stories that are on there almost all adhere to that rule. My dead GF on Facebook and the park ranger series being the best two examples. The protag dying doesn't really make the content any better, and the former story I mentioned kind of proves you can keep the ambiguity/stakes of the traditional horror "will they survive" if you're a decent enough writer. :marseyshrug:

Jump in the discussion.

No email address required.

Link copied to clipboard
Action successful!
Error, please refresh the page and try again.