BACKGROUND
Kenneth Eugene Smith, who was hired to murder Elizabeth Dorlene Sennett in 1988, will be executed with the first ever use of nitrogen to deprive the body of oxygen TOMORROW at 6pm CST in Atmore, Alabama. In November 2022, he was strapped to a gurney for over an hour, waiting for his lethal injection execution. It could not be done due to state officials unable to find a vein. After this, Smith advocated for his own execution by nitrogen hypoxia.
CONTROVERSY
Despite Smith himself asking for the method of execution, many people met on the steps of the Alabama State Capitol to protest this, calling it 'mental torture' and a 'gas chamber.' During the hearing to discuss whether it should be done, Alabama Solicitor General Edmund LaCour said it was βthe most humane method of execution ever devised.β
On the opposing side, Bernard Simelton, a member of the national committee of the NAACP, said at Tuesday's demonstration that the United Nations commissioner for human rights recently warned Smith's execution βcould amount to torture or other cruel, inhuman or degrading treatment or punishment under international human rights law.β
βThis is a sad day for the state of Alabama,β Simelton stated. βWe ask Governor Ivey to have a last-minute change of heart and do the right thing and halt this execution. The state does not understand the horror that this individual will go through. This is an experiment and we do not experiment on people.β
SCIENCE OF INERT GAS ASPHYXIATION
Nitrogen, as well as helium, argon, and methane, are able to reduce oxygen concentration in the blood, possibly causing effects at only one to two breaths. These include:
Unconsciousness
Low blood pressure
Cyanosis
Palpitations
Seizures
Mydriasis
Coma
And eventually, death
Inert gas asphyxiation would not cause the same response as if you held your breath. There are no carbon dioxide levels in the body rising, therefore your brain doesn't recognize that you are suffocating.
OPEN-ENDED POLL
Is this method of execution humane? Why or why not?
Jump in the discussion.
No email address required.
Literally every execution method besides the electric chair or stoning is less painful than lethal injection.
Jump in the discussion.
No email address required.
More options
Context