Jump in the discussion.

No email address required.

I thought The Sandman did such an excellent job of portraying how someone who sees himself as "a good guy" will still resort to sexual violence and be able to rationalize it. And why he's nor actually a "good guy" at all.

Then the author has to go and do this? Come on.

"Write what you know," they said...

Jump in the discussion.

No email address required.

>writers projecting :marseyprojection: into their works

Many such cases! E.g. Thomas Mann, Lewis Carroll, possibly GRRM and I hope not Vladimir Nabokov (it's possible he was molested by his uncle, besides Lolita preteen/teen s*x appears in at least 3 of his other works but there's nothing to indicate he was a p-do. Maybe being a victim of grooming is why he wrote about it?) !bookworms

Jump in the discussion.

No email address required.

Stephen King and ex-addicts/writers/Mainers

Jump in the discussion.

No email address required.

He got pissed at Kubrick for Jack Torrance's portrayal. According to King, Torrance was supposed to be a good father and an alcoholic fighting his demons. But Kubrick's take was that drunkards want to believe they're "jerks with a heart of gold" while in reality they're just buttholes damaging their families and lying to themselves.

Jump in the discussion.

No email address required.

I think that Kubrick rewrote the story to not be about alcoholism, but rather Jack dealing with deeply repressed homosexuality. Jack's internal struggle with being a homosexual when the outside world frowns on it is what causes him to snap. The Overlook Hotel is presented as a refuge where Jack has the freedom to reject society's beliefs. However, he is unable to do so in any healthy way, and so he resorts to violence against the heterosexual norm.

Kubrick, as director, is able to populate the set of the film with tiny thematic elements and props in a way a book cannot. In the little scenes we have outside the hotel, he establishes the overbearing, heterosexual world. Peepee Hallorann's bedroom, for instance, possesses two separate pictures of naked women. In a brief scene at the Snow-Mobile rental shop, we see a man flipping through a pin-up calendar, ogling the models on display. In a world where one should have women on one's mind, to go without one is to be an outcast. Hence, Jack married Wendy to fit in, and they had a son together. This family is the product of a loveless relationship that Jack does not wish to be a part of.

As soon as we arrive at the hotel, things are different. The manager for the hotel is named Ullman, which is pronounced as "All-men", hinting at who the Hotel is for. In a change from the book, instead of being unattractive and rude, he is a handsome gentleman who warmly welcomes Jack. Kubrick also rewrites Bill Watson, his assistant in the interview scene. There's weirdly gay-coded behavior between the two of them, and Jack straight ups says that he's looking for a "change" that the Overlook lifestyle would provide. By the way, while waiting in the hotel lobby, Jack is seen reading a magazine. Surprisingly, this magazine is "Playgirl". Why does the hotel provide this in the open, and why is Jack interested in erotic photographs of men? Because, of course, this hotel is a place where one is free to be gay.

Indeed, there are allusions in the film and book to why Jack left his teaching job. King makes it clear that he was let go because alcoholism was affecting his work. Kubrick is more vague, including only a reference to an "incident" with a male student. Was Jack caught trying to be in a relationship with them?

As mentioned, the set design is up to Kubrick. We are constantly faced with the imagery of identical twins, be it the twin girls, the two elevators, or even the fact that the pivotal room 237 has double doors. Since when does a hotel room have double doors at its entrance? All of these are Kubrick additions. Furthermore, plenty of shots are framed in such a way to show symmetry. Oftentimes, the exact same prop is on both sides of a character's face, especially Jack's. This effect of showing that twining exists in the hotel is designed to let us know one thing. Homosexual orientation, not heterosexual, is the norm here. Two things of the same type belong together and are accepted.

At first Jack tries to keep up the facade of heterosexuality. He tries to care for Wendy and Danny, but over time comes to realize he can't stand them, Wendy in particular. When he freaks out and curses at her for disturbing his writing, he is letting years of frustration out. She's his female ball and chain that the outside world demands he be shackled to. And to have her here, in this place of supposed freedom from the world, is unbearable to him. He wishes her gone unconsciously, as she is the physical presence of the oppression he has felt. Danny, as his son by her, is simply another manifestation of the painful relationship he has had to maintain. He loathes them both.

The memorable Room 237 scene is a two minute summary of Jack's sexual orientation. When Jack goes in to investigate Danny's claim of someone being in there, he comes across a beautiful woman. Nude in a tub, this is a fantasy of a straight man. Wordlessly, she approaches Jack, and he does what society expects him to and embraces her. However, as soon as he sees themselves in the mirror, something changes. She is not beautiful; she is hideous, old, rotten, and grotesque. This is how he feels about women. To him, even the most beautiful of girls is no more attractive to him than this corpse. He accepts this personal truth and flees the room.

We see Jack spending more time in the Gold Lounge, where he is able to interact with men, men who we are led to believe are the spirits of the hotel of the past. In an early conversation with Lloyd, the bartender, he mentions how he can't stand his wife, to which Lloyd answers, "Women, can't live with them; can't live without them." in an almost mocking fashion. In another significant ballroom interaction, a formally dressed waiter spills a tray of drinks on him. These drinks suspiciously resemble semen in color and texture, and the two of them end up in a bathroom to clean it up. Look at this scene. We''re informed that the Overlook has been meticulously maintained in its historic condition. Why does the bathroom not look like a bygone resort, but rather a place that would have been at home in a contemporary gay club? The cleaning is oddly sexual, as we see the waiter gingerly wipe the creamy liquid he has spilled on Jack off. We're voyeurs watching two men clean up after an anonymous hookup. All of this, I must reiterate, is Kubrick's invention.

It's revealed that the waiter is Grady, a former caretaker. In future conversations, he informs Jack about how the women in his life, his wife and daughters, held him back and detested the Overlook. He ultimately had to kill them, and he encourages Jack to do the same. It is not mere happenstance that at one point he literally frees Jack from a closet. He wants Jack to embrace his homosexuality and live the lifestyle that the Overlook represents.

Perhaps the most iconic creation of Kubrick is the "All work and no play makes Jack a dull boy" reveal. This is simply Jack writing out his inner thoughts. He detests the work of being in a heterosexual relationship and wishes to engage in homosexual behavior, which in the real world is often referred to as "play" by the gay community.

There's also the mysterious bear scene, where Wendy encounters a man fellating another man. They are dressed in period-appropriate costumes for the Overlook's parties. Bear is an obvious homosexual reference here. We, the audience, are once again shown the sexual escape that the Overlook allows, namely men to have sexual relationships with men. Wendy freaks out and flees. This is her, and heterosexual society at large, reacting to Jack's orientation.

Jump in the discussion.

No email address required.

https://i.rdrama.net/images/17025509830829637.webp

Jump in the discussion.

No email address required.

Eh i like the "drunks are bad" take more

Jump in the discussion.

No email address required.

King was most likely upset because Jack is King (sans the success), Stephen King probably saw that take on Jack as a personal attack on his drunk butt.

Jump in the discussion.

No email address required.

King broke his son's arm in a drunken rage.

Jump in the discussion.

No email address required.

Never learn how the sausage is made or in this case used

Jump in the discussion.

No email address required.

:#marseyfeminist:

Jump in the discussion.

No email address required.

Ah, I thought that a r*pe scene was missing from that episode.

Jump in the discussion.

No email address required.

Link copied to clipboard
Action successful!
Error, please refresh the page and try again.