Also he's wasn't even trans. He told every journ*list that he's a dude that likes to crossdress.

CuckGPT

Marsha P. Johnson: Identity and Role in Stonewall

Marsha P. Johnson is widely celebrated as a pivotal figure in LGBTQ+ history, particularly for her involvement in the Stonewall Riots and advocacy for transgender rights. However, discussions about her identity and specific role in these events reveal a more nuanced picture.

Identity and Terminology

During her lifetime, the term "transgender" was not commonly used. Johnson referred to herself using various terms, including "gay," "transvestite," and "queen" (in the context of drag queen or "street queen"). She often used female pronouns but did not explicitly identify as transgender, as the term gained prominence after her death in 1992. Susan Stryker, a professor of gender and sexuality studies, noted that Johnson's gender expression could be described as gender non-conforming.

(Source: Wikipedia)

Role in the Stonewall Riots

While Johnson is a prominent figure associated with the Stonewall Riots, her exact involvement on the first night is subject to debate. Some accounts suggest she was present, while others indicate she arrived after the initial outbreak. Both Johnson and fellow activist Sylvia Rivera have, at times, denied being present at the start of the riots.

(Source: Wikipedia)

Conclusion

In summary, while Marsha P. Johnson is undeniably a significant figure in LGBTQ+ history, the specific labels regarding her identity and her precise actions during the Stonewall Riots are complex and have been interpreted in various ways over time.

Deepseek

Based on the provided search results, here are the key sources and arguments that challenge the attribution of Marsha P. Johnson as a transgender woman and her role in initiating the Stonewall uprising:

1. Marsha P. Johnson's Self-Identification

• Not Explicitly Identifying as Transgender: Johnson referred to herself as a "gay person," "transvestite," and "drag queen" during her lifetime. The term "transgender" was not widely used in her era, and she did not adopt it explicitly. She often used both male and female pronouns and rejected rigid gender labels, famously stating her middle initial "P" stood for "Pay It No Mind" when questioned about her gender .

• Historical Context: In the 1960s–70s, terms like "transvestite" and "drag queen" were distinct from modern "transgender" identities. Johnson's fluid expression complicates retroactive labeling .

2. Disputed Role in the Stonewall Uprising

• Johnson's Own Account: In a 1987 interview, Johnson stated she arrived at the Stonewall Inn after the riots had begun (around 2 a.m.), contradicting claims that she "started" the uprising. She described the scene as already chaotic: "The place was already on fire... the riots had already started" .

• Eyewitness Corroboration: Other accounts attribute the uprising's ignition to Stormé DeLarverie, a butch lesbian who resisted arrest, or a collective response to police violence. Police reports and contemporaneous testimonies do not name Johnson as the instigator .

• Myth vs. Reality: While Johnson participated actively in the riots (e.g., dropping objects on police cars), narratives crediting her with "throwing the first brick" or initiating the resistance are largely mythologized in later retellings .

3. Historical Revisionism and Activist Narratives

• Modern Reinterpretation: Recent activism has emphasized Johnson as a "trans woman of color" to align with intersectional frameworks, despite historical ambiguity. Critics argue this revisionism prioritizes identity politics over factual accuracy .

• Contradictions in Sources: Sylvia Rivera, Johnson's close collaborator, was also inconsistently described as present during the first night of Stonewall. Some accounts suggest Rivera was absent or unconscious in a park during the initial clash .

4. Institutional and Cultural Erasure Debates

• National Park Service Revisions: In 2025, the Trump administration removed transgender references from the Stonewall National Monument website, sparking backlash. Critics argued this erasure mirrored historical exclusion of trans figures like Johnson, while others noted the complexity of retroactively applying modern labels .

• Legacy vs. Accuracy: While Johnson's contributions to LGBTQ+ activism (e.g., co-founding STAR House) are undisputed, debates persist about framing her identity and Stonewall role through a contemporary lens .

Key Sources Challenging Common Attributions

1. Reason.com Article (2020): Questions Johnson's transgender identity and Stonewall leadership role, citing her own words and historical context .

SHOW MORE

There would need to be more evidence that they were part of that history, not just drag queens and other crossdressers.

Gitmo will need a second McDonald's

If he did that, he still wouldn't have come for anyone who would have stood up for me.