mumsnet discusses what is a woman (12 pages of seethe)

https://www.mumsnet.com/talk/womens_rights/5139210-what-is-a-woman

>It's that there's

>a) no publicly available evidence for the xy chromosome result - if there is please can someone post the source?

>b) if you read the famous lancet article on the trans debate which covers xy chromosomes and s*x and dsds you will realise that a Y chromosome is not a literal letter Y, it is four chromatids of differing lengths and therefore not a neatly packaged thing

>c) evidence for higher testosterone, which essentially means nothing. I am currently pregnant with a baby boy, my testosterone levels are also above the cutoff point so presumably that means I am male too? despite having a human being kicking me in the ribs right now!?

>d) mn keyboard warriors saying Imane Khelif is a man is just offensive to someone who was born female and raised female, and had to face so much sexism in her life to even be able to enter boxing. I feel bad for her.

>e) mn keyboard warriors are actually using the same argument as the TRAs is ironic

>f) comments like the one above about Muslim countries pisses me off

>g) snopes and other fact check organisations say she was born and lived her entire life as female, and is not trans, and has not transitioned. She is not a man and she has never been a man.

>I see the possibility that a woman, who was born female, who was brought up female, who had to face sexism on her boxing journey because 'it's not feminine', who was part of controversial chromosome testing where I have seen no actual publicly available evidence that she has xy chromosomes, who has female body parts, who has high levels of testosterone, I think she has wrongly been accused of being male when all along she's just some girl who is a boxer. I just think it's worth considering this point. And that in the event that someone has all the female anatomy and things I describe above, how awful that people all over the world are going round being like 'it's a man it's a man'.

>But Khelif is a man, who based on the publicly-available information, has a DSD only men can have.

>He wasn't born female, he was misidentified by the doctor only having a cursory glance at what looked like a vulva.

TIL: shit is complicated and mumsnet bends the definitions to exclude ugly women/DSDs lmao

Jump in the discussion.

No email address required.

Chapose Asuna/Kirito I would kill to kill a waifu. 3mo ago #6862802

He wasn't born female, he was misidentified by the doctor only having a cursory glance at what looked like a vulva.

Lmao and the parents never noticed?

4 Context

Bruhfunny_Thrall xhe/xhem :marseybruh:

3mo ago #6861854

Tf is this website, /r/Breakingmom 2.0? :#brookslaugh: !nonchuds how many TERFs on this site you wanna bet lost custody of xeir children :#shyyt:

24 Context

Budgerigar drinky/budgie :parrotcongaparty:

By reading my posts you agree to my Terms and Agreements. :parrot!congaparty:

Bruhfunny_Thrall 3mo ago #6862192

lost custody of xeir children

The term in 15th trimester pillow abortion, moid!

:marsey#maid5:

6 Context

jesus je/sus :chadjesus:

Budgerigar 3mo ago #6862871

:#marseywould:

2 Context

Brony UNDER/TALE Cream Ponut Factory Bruhfunny_Thrall 3mo ago #6862387

>how many TERFs on this site you wanna bet lost custody of xeir children

Err, 0? :marseyshrug:

Seriously. Have you ever seen a mother lose custody? :marseyconfused: Even in the US it's rare. :marseygolden2:

5 Context

DestoryerCarbine sae/less Only real g*mer on this entire site Bruhfunny_Thrall 3mo ago #6862891

More like 1.0 lol OLD website

1 Fetch/Beans (colonially know as xirabolt) 3mo ago #6860179

Wow, wait until she learns that the nucleotide bases in DNA aren't actually in the shape of A, C, G, or T.

Type B+ blood doesn't have any in it!

46 Context

1 3mo ago #6860315

54 Context

BussydoFollower Gay/Chud :marseyfluffy:

The world is made in an adorable way :marseyfluffy:

jesus 3mo ago #6860811

!pepe

17 Context

SonamyEXEShippingCompany Ro/man/ce Que tal, wey? :marseymariachi:

jesus 3mo ago #6862539

I think this was the plot of Bee Movie or something idk :marseybee:

!kino

12 Context

The_ACA The/The The SonamyEXEShippingCompany 3mo ago #6863252

I love me some Jerry Seinfeld

Kiwibee they/them 1 3mo ago #6861200

:marseysoycry: STOP LYING

1 3mo ago #6862196

Daadass derogatory to those under the blood-to-bees curse

X ching/chong :marseyrevolution:

Anarcho-Syndicalist-Trotskyist-Stalinist Cuban Revolutionary :!marseydragon2:

3mo ago #6860282

!transphobes

:#marseytranscope:

28 Context

zombiecel short/bus Death to all rightoids :!marseyshooting:

X 3mo ago #6862386

https://nyaspubs.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/abs/10.1111/j.2164-0947.1967.tb02279.x

I guess a woman is someone who's smarter than you :marseygiggle:

zombiecel 3mo ago #6862675

Being smarter than me is not difficult :marseysob:

The_ACA The/The The X 3mo ago #6861317

Needs to be laboratory grade NGL, preferably HPLC

!chemistry

9 Context

Pelican they/them 3mo ago #6859478

mumsnet bends the definitions to exclude ugly women

Mumsnet consists purely of yummy mummys

30 Context

The_ACA The/The The Pelican 3mo ago #6860112

A mummy pinned this thread

15 Context

Pelican 3mo ago #6862199

rdrama foids :marseyvenn5: mumsnet yumiiies

reddit_lies Reddit/Lies yes it's really me 3mo ago #6859577

Kleif isn't an "ugly woman". He's just a normal :marseychartgaussian: looking :marseyflirt: man with a fricked up peepee

https://archive.is/Viip4

23 Context

Redactor0 naori/oppa The Rachel Dolezal of Maronite Christians. reddit_lies 3mo ago #6860502

In a video posted online, Khelif accused another country for the disqualification, calling the entire incident a "conspiracy" to bring the boxer down (Khelif was accusing Morocco).

:marseyschizowall: :marseylaugh:

I love the Algeria vs. Morocco thing so much. The level of hatred and paranoia is amazing for two countries that aren't at war with each other.

22 Context

Szechenyi trans/lajta O brave new world! How beauteous mankind is! Redactor0 3mo ago #6862402

Two morrocan buddies once invited me at their place and they were chilling by watching a documentary on Algeria's attempt to destroy Morocco

starry boy/mode starry eyed boymoder reddit_lies 3mo ago #6859629

suppose that she does have xy chromosomes -- i dont see why that would matter or how it would make her a man/inelligble to compete. it sounds like she has lived as a woman all of her life and never had male puberty, so what's the big deal?

also, its interesting (alarming) how your source neglects to mention that the IOC broke ties with IBA for unrelated corruption.

>Disqualifying Khelif did not benefit any Russian competitor.

false, it restored the undefeated status of a Russian boxer that Khelif defeated

8 Context

starry 3mo ago #6860283

>she

:#marseypenis:

19 Context

Cdace Dino/Dinos i fricking love Parasaurolophus so much :chudsaurolophuslove:

jesus 3mo ago #6860443 🍎🍀👣 Lost 100 coins

!slots100

Cdace 3mo ago #6860472

:#dinover: :#dinosaurxd:

7 Context

reddit_lies Reddit/Lies yes it's really me starry 3mo ago #6859637

I identify as a gorilla :marseykong2: and have done so all my life. Let me compete on 2000mg of testosterone :marseysoycrytremble: or you're a bigot :marseyracist:

starry boy/mode starry eyed boymoder reddit_lies 3mo ago #6860297

sure. go compete with the other gorillas, cant wait to see how this turns out

ElverGalarga El/Rey starry 3mo ago #6863081

I think I can do it

1 Context

IanMyhrrdock deb/ian buttplug driver maintainer reddit_lies 3mo ago #6859905

That analogy doesn't work unless you're in the gorilla category in the olympics

Elise_Culpepper Fae/Fay Sister(Brother) of the Arcanum of Norfolk IanMyhrrdock 3mo ago #6860743

Sounds pretty fricking racist to me

11 Context

IanMyhrrdock 3mo ago #6860288

:#nerd:

IanMyhrrdock deb/ian buttplug driver maintainer jesus 3mo ago #6862258

:marseyme:

reddit_lies Reddit/Lies yes it's really me IanMyhrrdock 3mo ago #6860910

ElverGalarga El/Rey reddit_lies 3mo ago #6863087

Why can't we let then use and and all PEDs/cybernetic enhancements?

Sports would be a lot cooler

yoni zzz/zzz starry 3mo ago #6859698

No he's a well 5-ARD peepeelet thug :!marseypunching:

ElverGalarga El/Rey starry 3mo ago #6863077

https://x.com/mylordbebo/status/1820440421136269780

This Krokodil Kween wants a rematch, too.

garlicdoors ahoy/hoy :marseypop2:

3mo ago #6859376

:#chudturbospergout2: I want to know what mums think about Southport!!!

14 Context

DEV0T10 nothing/wrong Trans Inclusive Radical Misogynist 3mo ago #6862260

All this genetic shit is above my understanding so I'm going to go with the :grug: stance that if your born with a vagina you're a woman. And yeah the Algerian lady is a genetic freak but you should expect most of the worlds top athletes to be genetic freaks.

>But it's unfair that she's stronger than normal women :marseytradmad:

there's a basketball player that's 7 and a half feet tall.

DestoryerCarbine sae/less Only real g*mer on this entire site DEV0T10 3mo ago #6862889

She's a genetic freak in the sense of being born with internal male genitalia lol

The_ACA The/The The 3mo ago #6860125

DSD, and specifically androgen insensitivity, is not a variation on a beautiful spectrum of sexual development. Rather, having XY chromosomes yet developing a female phenotype is the result of a deleterious genetic defect.

You will look like a woman but you will never be a woman, and you will never reproduce. !ifrickinglovescience !biology

You are not sexually developed if you cannot reproduce.

Sorry but sometimes shit sucks.

13 Context

Redactor0 naori/oppa The Rachel Dolezal of Maronite Christians. The_ACA 3mo ago #6860520

I'm really getting sick of this attitude wokies have everyone should always be able to do whatever they want. I'd love to be out there competing in the 100m dash. Unfortunately I'm a cripple so I just can't ever do that. That's nobody's fault, I just have a medical condition that disqualifies me. These boxers do too.

It's like the fricking magic wheelchairs in D&D where you can be a crip and there's no negative consequences at all. Whenever I see this shit I know it's got to be coming from people who had really easy lives, because most of us didn't have the chance to do whatever we wanted in life.