emoji-award-marseytrain
Unable to load image
Reported by:

Tumblr Hogwarts Legacy Seethe Compliation :marseythegrey: :!marseyrage: :marseysoypoint:

https://old.reddit.com/r/CuratedTumblr/comments/11gtrj0/hogwarts_legacy_megapost_i_probably_wont_be

![](/images/16778596045397396.webp)

![](/images/16778596043051531.webp)

![](/images/16778596040831141.webp)

![](/images/1677859603942739.webp)

![](/images/16778596037855015.webp)

![](/images/16778596032889035.webp)

![](/images/16778596030425918.webp)

Tumblr is still mad about Hogwarts Legacy. User posts a compilation of posts about it to reddit, surely everyone agrees wizard game bad :marseyclueless:

About slide 4, I don't think simply consuming a piece of media means you agree with it or support its messages. You can play the game while thinking the story is horrible, you have not given monetary support to the people who are espousing these beliefs, I don't see what's wrong with that. Simply engaging with a story doesn't mean praising the story.

Reading Mein Kampf and shaking my head the whole time so people on the bus know I disagree with it

:marseyhitler:

the first one is hilariously overdramatic. grow up, nobody is going to be permanently haunted by the sin of buying a video game

I know people don’t want to support Rowling, which I believe is good, but the way some people react you’d think playing this game equates to manslaughter. Responsible media consumption is good but some people have lost their sense of scope with it. Also at this point publicly announcing you’re boycotting it is just free advertising for the game, so.

It's a sort of 'minumum effort' kind of deal. If you can't support the trans community by literally just not buying and playing a single video game, arguably one of the easiest, least impactful things you could possibly do to show support, then how can anyone in the trans community expect you to take any sort of action as an ally to aid them? If you can't literally do nothing to support them, it implies you also wouldn't take action to support them. It screams, at the very best, 'I'll support you as long as it doesn't inconvenience me in any way'. Which is not any actual, real support.

:marseyhesright:

Reminder that the majority of people have no clue what the struggles of the trans community are. So you have these uninformed people (i know some people that thought the whole discourse was because there was no trans character in HL to tell you how UNINFORMED some people are) you're calling them their nazis for playing a video game and sending them death threats and wave after wave of bullying for something they have no idea of what it's about. How do you think they'll react? :marseywords:

jkr is donating her cuts from the game’s profit directly to anti trans charities. Anyone who buys the game contributes to that. Boiling it down to “harassed over vidya 😡” ignores WHY people are upset.

And sending death threats to people helps fix that how exactly? You think people are aware of it? You think harassed people are aware of it? At the end of the day for them you're just harassing them over a video game, period. And once again harassing people doesnt fix anything, it just paints the people you're trying to help as agressors and gives transphobes the perfect reason to recruit people to their side. You've hurt everyone except the ones you're fighting against. Congrats.

Hmmmmm. If you’re being harassed

And the Harassment involves telling you that you’ve just donated to an anti trans charity

And you still don’t understand why

You’re an idiot. Straight up.

Okay, which part of "you're a nazi you should die" says "you've just donated to an anti trans charity"

Did you pass your 3rd grade reading comprehension tests

I think that people ignoring the multiple instances of antisemetic-like happenings in the game often leads others to think that they, you know, are in support of said antisemitism.

Also, you responded to a comment about the transphobic nature of giving money to grand terf jkr by cherry picking a strawman about nazis. Great comeback buddy! You’ve truly destroyed all trans people.

This turns into a big argument with /u/moop-doop ("You're an idiot. Straight up") calling someone unhinged :marseylaugh:

lmao just dont fund it then (this post was made by the piracy gang)

Didn't you read ?

Playing this game, even without paying anything for it, make you a turbotransphobe that want to kill jews.

:marseyhitler2:

I like how only one of these are actually trying to explain WHY the game is antisemitic/transphobic the rest are basically just screaming at you "Game is bad and you should feel bad!". To just keep being loud and angry about something likely isn't gonna win anyone over, they're just not gonna engage with the (hostile) conversation and play the stupid wizard game in the secrecy of their home where they can't be judged for it

" I like how only one of these are actually trying to explain WHY the game is antisemitic/transphobic"

google exists, dude. I'm not gonna go around personally yelling at people and if you take a single look at my post history all i've been doing to people who disagree with me is explaining.

Just fricking google it. holy shit, use your goddarn brains, and if you can't do that, use your fingers to type "what is wrong with buying hogwarts legacy trans" into google dot com. Everybody is so fricking braindead.

Everyone is indeed braindead :marseybigbrain:

My thoughts on HL is that if you cannot somehow avoid buying or playing it despite the pretty big antisemtic dogwhistles and the fact that supporting it by extension supports jkr (who cites her continued success as proof that transphobia is good and the norm), you shouldn't be surprised if trans people don't feel comfortable or trust you. because if you can't get over the hurdle of "don't play this game", how the heck can you be expected to pass hurdles like "the government is trying to legistrate us out of existence, please help us fight back"?

Are there specific plot points in hogwarts legacy that are an anti-semitic theme, cause if you think the goblins look like Jewish people then the anti-Semitic call is coming from inside the house. EDIT: Explain it to me.

"I didnt hear the dog whistle, so that must mean you guys are making up being able to hear it."

:marseybriansus:

I bought the game and I loved every second of it despite everyone's attempts to ruin my fun. No, you didn't manage to spoil me. In actuality, the fact that I knew there was something to spoil actually made me wonder what it was, so during the whole game, I thought Fig was actually unapologetically evil, which gave him a character tone which was so awesome. I was SO sure up until the very last scene he was in that he was evil. So, thanks everyone for making my HL playthrough actually better than the one I would have had if you HADN'T tipped me off there was content to spoil. Now, do I support every viewpoint ever made by anyone whose things I've ever purchased? No, honestly, I couldn't care one bit what Rowlings views are. Nor have I ever supported Mark Twain, or HP Lovecraft. And those two buttholes were ten leagues worse than her. Because if we wanna get real fricking technical here, with this screwed logic, most of us support genocide by purchasing devices containing Chinese circuits.

You literally could have just not bought the game, we can't choose to be luddites without crippling ourselves

Frick you for helping the movement to kill trans people

185
Jump in the discussion.

No email address required.

It's funny seeing them push the antisemitism angle, not because they care about the jews but because their transphobia complaints gained no traction so they are trying to leech off the jews to achieve their goals. The problem is there is less merit behind the antisemitism claims than the JKR is a transphobe one.

Also, what are they even hoping to accomplish at this point? The game is already a massive success and that can't be taken away.

Jump in the discussion.

No email address required.

The claim was that by buying the game, then you were giving money to support and fund anti-trans legislation in the UK, because JK Rowling supported groups which sponsored anti-trans legislation.

However, fair enough, boycotting is one thing, however the issue is they caused a backlash by trying to intimidate people into not playing the game and made hyperbolic claims about how playing the game was supporting "transgenocide".

The thing with a lot of these woke trans, is that they think they are at the same social level as groups such as the Jews and black people who have experienced real instances of human rights abuse, when transgender people haven't exactly had that yet. They don't realize that in order for a community to gain rights and recognition, there is typically a period of oppression such as a massacre or genocide. Not to be hyperbolic but most of these people are going to detransition and leave actual transgender people to fend for themselves when they start putting people in camps. We are headed towards the period of oppression and human rights abuse, but a lot of it is as an effect of these Queer activists co-opting the transgender community and a reaction against that.

I'm not trying to be reactionary, but just about any train expects there to be a period or episode of a human rights abuse towards a disenfranchised community, but I believe that this period is commonly needed in order to get public recognition and acceptance.

With the way the public rhetoric is headed towards trains, I do expect to live through a genocide, massacre or some kind of human rights abuse, but I realize It's part of the natural order and other communities have had to go through it.

Jump in the discussion.

No email address required.

literally nobody is putting :!marseytrain:s in camps, at least not in any developed nation.

you are right though, that if that were to happen, most of the agp freaks would just detrans and turn back into "regular" coomers

Jump in the discussion.

No email address required.

It's happened before in developed nations including the US, and I think something could happen again, especially when the public discourse is designed to dehumanize transgender people.

Are we there yet? No. However, at this time it's not yet probable but it is possible. The probability of some kind of episode of human rights abuse towards transgender people is increasing each and every day.

Jump in the discussion.

No email address required.

Lol there is a 0% chance that trans people face any real threats in the foreseeable future. The only thing that might happen is that politicians stop caring about them and they finally move out of public focus.

Jump in the discussion.

No email address required.

The politicians are the ones trying to keep them in the public focus to drive reactivity against them.

If you think I'm getting reactive against it, instead of being aware and keeping in mind that it is a possibility, I'm not.

Jump in the discussion.

No email address required.

The politicians are the ones trying to keep them in the public focus

Yes

to drive reactivity against them.

Nah. Maybe some right wing politicians do, but lefties (and Id assume most righoids too) only do it to pander to their base. Trains are simply a tool to show your voters how bad the other side is. If they shifted out of the public interest politicians would stop talking about them. They dont because trains do a lot of unhinged shit because most of them are mentally ill (apart from body dysphoria) and journos lap that up, and politicians bank on the outrage.

But most politicians wont have any interest in a trans genocide happening, Id even go as far as to say that a lot of them still have enough morals to not want a genocide happen (though that might be giving politicians too much credit).

Plus theres probably also a corporate interest in not having a group of people in your country genocided.

Jump in the discussion.

No email address required.

State-mandated hormone therapy risperidone and lithium treatment for :marseytrain: would get my vote :marseyagreefast:

𝕊𝕙𝔸𝕜𝔼𝕪 𝕊𝕙𝔸𝕜𝔼𝕪 :marseymeds: 𝕥𝕀𝕞𝔼 𝕥𝕆 𝕥𝔸𝕜𝔼𝕪

Jump in the discussion.

No email address required.

It's happened before in developed nations including the US

What are you even thinking of here? The Japanese internment camps during WW2? That's the only even remotely-recent event that matches, but it's so dramatically different from current-day :marseytrain: politics that you must be thinking of something else.

Jump in the discussion.

No email address required.

Japs weren't even genocided. The economic damage was awful, and they weren't truly compensated for it, but they weren't death camps. There's a world of difference between the Japanese internment camps and full-on death camps in Nazi Germany.

Jump in the discussion.

No email address required.

Good point. How the US treated Japanese-American citizens was disgraceful and unethical, but we weren't starving them to death or mass murdering them like both the Nazis and Japs did to their own "undesirables".

I sometimes have to remind people that the Japanese were easily more racist and just as evil as the Nazis. They used to force prisoners to r*pe each other to contract syphilis and then they would cut them open and dissect them while they were still alive, with no painkillers because literally "why waste painkillers on a subhuman?" It's just that the victims were mostly other Asians and nobody in the West really cared much about it.

Jump in the discussion.

No email address required.

For real the atrocities by Imperial Japan are fricked.

Jump in the discussion.

No email address required.

For me, it's just being emotionally and mentally prepared for the worst case scenario and realizing that the probability of the worst case scenario is increasing each and every day.

Jump in the discussion.

No email address required.

u said this just yesterday...so what is it..live ur best life or prepare for nonexistent camps bc ur so fricking delusional ![](/images/16778824465475879.webp)

Jump in the discussion.

No email address required.

I was thinking of the Japanese internment camps, the native American massacres, segregation, slavery, the holocaust.

Things are getting more and more reactive in the political climate each and every day, and extremism is increasing on all levels. The thing is, reactivity against it from the transgender community is just making it increase.

The thing is, people are getting sick of everyone co-opting the transgender community and the normal transgender people who just want to live their lives are pretty much ostracized from their own community and are also affected by the rhetoric, because they are placed into the same category.

Jump in the discussion.

No email address required.

I guess they might seem similar if you ignore all context lol.

In 1941 when the japs surprise bombed pearl harbor, they were a country run by the military, that would say anything and do anything for success. This is after they spent the last few years committing terrible massacres all over SEA, so it's not without precedent. We created the internment camps for them and not germans because (a) the germans didn't bomb us on our own soil and (b) the japs were very much more fanatical than the rank-and-file germans.

Not to defend the camps, I think they ultimately weren't worth the cost and were a poor decision as a result, but you really have to put yourself in the mindset of someone in 1941 to see why they were created and tolerated by the public. Not to mention that the general public - not just in the US but everywhere around the world - was far less tolerant in general back then than they are now.

Nothing like that exists for :!marseytrain:s. Not even a tiny, little bit. Maybe if all of them formed a cult and killed tons of US military service members with a large navy and air force capable of doing even more serious damage to the nation you'd have a point. But that's just not reality.

tldr if you think :marseytrain: camps are even a remote possibility you're one of the more r-slurred users on this site

Jump in the discussion.

No email address required.

I'm just being mentally and emotionally prepared for the worst case scenario, which the probability is increasing each and every day.

Not camps exactly.

Jump in the discussion.

No email address required.

lmao okay. If you want to live your life in fear of something that's not gonna happen then you do you. It sounds like a miserable and unhealthy way to choose to go through life but I support your freedom to be miserable.

Jump in the discussion.

No email address required.

More comments

What a cop out lol

Jump in the discussion.

No email address required.

More comments

If only you could put that energy into your relationships

Jump in the discussion.

No email address required.

>mention five things that used to be routine in human history and dont happen anymore

Oh yeah reaction and hate are certainly on the rise. In the 70s, RuPauls drag race was at its height and HRT was in every water fountain. Now people look at trans people and think "weird."

Jump in the discussion.

No email address required.

extremism is increasing on all levels. The thing is, reactivity against it from the transgender community

See this is the kind of bullshit wishy-washy no evidence kind of talk that :!marseytrain:s keep abusing, at the cost to actually oppressed groups in the world. Things have only been getting better for transpeople, as the majority of them in the US that were being "genocided" were pretty much lower income prostitutes, most of which are completely removed from the online incel-to-train pipeline. Most MtF trains these days don't even leave their basements, and justify that with "I'll be killed in the streets" when people who are far less privileged than they are and suffer higher mortality rates are fine going out and about with their business.

The trans-community needs to have a reckoning with the ever-increasing amount of failed nerd moids that keep trying to shit up their movement. Many of them are so detached from reality there's no way their opinions on gender should be respected, let alone their opinions on politics. Your ideas about le trans genocide is a complete self-serving delusion when in reality the majority of :!marseytrain:s are from the most privileged groups in America: heterosexual white males and females.

Jump in the discussion.

No email address required.

It’s no use trying to reason with this :marseytrain:, apparently he’s a diagnosed :marseyschizotwitch: so you’ll have a better chance of convincing them that the tapioca pudding in the fridge isn’t sending their thoughts to the CIA before you convince them that :marseytransgenocide: isn’t happening

Jump in the discussion.

No email address required.

That's as likely as White Genocide, are FEMA death camps in your predictions as well, maybe Bill Gates depopulation.

Jump in the discussion.

No email address required.

n us foids r called histrionic ffs lookit this whole butt whyte man invent a completely insane narrative jfc 🙄🙄

Jump in the discussion.

No email address required.

tru tru but also penny lets :marseybee: real here would u sign up to be a guard at a :marseytrain: prison camp?

Jump in the discussion.

No email address required.

:marseyxd: tempest bb jfc i work in healthcare my irl job is comfort n caring for the elderly i doubt i could do that...but...u kno how powerless people get insane when they get a bit of power? ye let's not try me :marseysweating:

Jump in the discussion.

No email address required.

u kno how powerless people get insane when they get a bit of power?

def not uncommon in healthcare settings :marseysweating: feels like every year there's at least one crazy nurse who murders a patient on purpose :marseydead:

anyways i'm gonna take note :marseynotes: that despite really hating :!marseytrain:s u apparently aren't down with physically abusing them :marseywholesome:

Jump in the discussion.

No email address required.

jfc no 🙏🏾🙏🏾 in a fight mb but they got scrote stretbtgh n i been beat down by moids b4 so not gonna tussle

Jump in the discussion.

No email address required.

"If you don't do X then I'll kill myself."

See, it's genocide.

Jump in the discussion.

No email address required.

I do expect to live through an actual genocide or massacre in my lifetime targeted towards the transgender community. I think a lot of transgender people see the tides turning and a lot of it is reactivity, because things are headed there.

It is hyperbolic to claim things are currently there or at that level.

I discourage transgender people from transitioning by saying that they are in an unstable political climate and the wheels are turning against transgender people, and they are being put on the forefront of politics and they have to probably be prepared for what they may face, which does include genocide.

If you aren't strong enough to face the possibility of some kind of human rights abuse targeted towards you, then don't transition and get out of the fire.

Jump in the discussion.

No email address required.

If you unironically expect that you need to spend less time on the internet. at most their "rights" (grooming children on groomercord, buying unvalidated bathtub HRT from brazil, stealing women's luggage, getting medically validated to chop their peepee off) will have actual scrutiny behind it

Either that or a pill is developed that "solves" gender dysphoria. I guess that could count as a genocide if you're r-slurred


Give me your money and I'll annoy people with it :space: https://i.rdrama.net/images/16965516366194396.webp

Jump in the discussion.

No email address required.

I don't think it's probable, but it is possible that in the future there will be some sort of human rights abuse towards transgender people.

What I do think is possible is that things are going to get really ugly politically, socially, etc towards transgender people as a whole.

My opinion is due to the drastic changes in the perception of transgender people as a whole, even among normies from going outside, and experiencing it.

Jump in the discussion.

No email address required.

Yeah, and they have that change in perception due to the overabundance of genuine creeps and the complete inability for leftists in general to take the L and not defend complete, unironic degenerates

"please don't misgender a male feminist who now identifies as a woman" tier shit. ofc people are gonna have a negative perception of that kinda thing.

But to pretend it's going to ever get worse than "people laughing @ you on the internet" or "people don't think you're actually a woman" is so astoundingly delusional that you should win an award for it.


Give me your money and I'll annoy people with it :space: https://i.rdrama.net/images/16965516366194396.webp

Jump in the discussion.

No email address required.

Well, too many :!marseytrain:s are willing to be the cowtools in the elites' humiliation ritual against white Westerners. Of course people are going to be angry. They're going to remember you guys destroying people because they won't call q peepee feminine

Jump in the discussion.

No email address required.

gatekeep out the tu-cutes and fetishists and you'll be fine. Don't take people on their word unless they have some kind of certificate about their dysphoria. And stop confusing impressionable kids about their gender.

Shit like this is exactly why past subcultures/movements did gatekeeping and respectability politics.

The problem is, doing something right is less noticeable than doing something wrong, so people assumed the above was a flaw with the movements, rather than their greatest strength.

What you're seeing now is the effect of leaderless movements letting their ranks fill with complete refuse. They disgust the honest folk.

Shampoo your greasy hair and wash your clothes before you think of going outside to rep a community.


:#marseydarkpizzashill: The Democratic RethugliKKKan Party will collapse by 2030. :#marseydarkpizzashill:

Jump in the discussion.

No email address required.

It's far more likely we're going to see increasing "isolated cases" of trans-individuals commit extremely abhorrent acts of violence and sexual violence due to the fact that they have no gatekeeping and actively protect their most deranged individuals out of a sense of mutual entitlement.

Jump in the discussion.

No email address required.

It'll be the first time a genocide/massacre occurred over sometime that can be cured with therapy or kept hidden by just shutting the frick up.

They're always "fearing for their lives" but go way out of their way to makes their transgenderism known to everyone


https://i.rdrama.net/images/17191743323420358.webp

Jump in the discussion.

No email address required.

okay, but seriously, in your mind what does a "trans genocide" look like? because trying to equate mean comments on the internet and not allowing minors to transition as equal to shit like the holocaust or Rwanda, don't really carry the same weight.

Jump in the discussion.

No email address required.

It's not mean comments on the internet. We aren't there yet as a society. Nothing major will probably occur for a few more years.

I don't know what it looks like, but it doesn't look like that. I expect it reflects other instances of human rights abuses present in history as extremism increases against transgender people.

Jump in the discussion.

No email address required.

Okay, if that's what you think then okay. But I think your hyping yourself up for something that's ultimately going to fizzle out.

Jump in the discussion.

No email address required.

:marseysal:


https://i.rdrama.net/images/17191743323420358.webp

Jump in the discussion.

No email address required.

>when they start putting people in camps

:#marseytinfoil:

Jump in the discussion.

No email address required.

I'm not saying it's probable, but it's possible.

With the way the political climate is trying to present trans people as p-dophiles and dehumanize them so people don't react towards human rights abuses, you should only transition with the expectation that you will experience ostracization, violence, harassment, and some kind of human rights abuse in the future.

It's not unrealistic to claim that things are headed there, it is hyperbolic to claim things are currently at that level.

Jump in the discussion.

No email address required.

trying to present trans people as p-dophiles

If you want to avoid that perception wouldn't you agree that children should be left out of all this?

Jump in the discussion.

No email address required.

I think it's a medical condition and some kids need treatment. I believe in strengthening gatekeeping for minors and assessment instead of banning outright which I view as an reactionary measure.

Jump in the discussion.

No email address required.

Do you really believe that children, who can't legally consent, vote, etc., and whose brains are very much still in development, can really make the determination that they are trans without any outside influence? And then begin something as potentially life-altering as hormone therapy?

Jump in the discussion.

No email address required.

I think if they can get treatment for other medical conditions such as chemotherapy for leukemia or SSRIs for depression, they should have the option to receive HRT in legitimate cases of gender dysphoria, as long as they have a diagnosis and caution is used.

Yes.

Jump in the discussion.

No email address required.

You need mental health treatment my friend, everything you've written from thinking that a trans-genocide is a real possibility to comparing chemotherapy treatments to HRT for children show massive signs of not being in the right headspace. This type of thinking occurs in other, non-trans individuals too and it's a sign of paranoia that's not consistent with reality.

Jump in the discussion.

No email address required.

More comments

zoz

Jump in the discussion.

No email address required.

More comments

And if there's a treatment that involves kids accepting their bodies as they are? Oh right that's a heckin hate crimerino

Jump in the discussion.

No email address required.

That is what the therapy should be for, and the therapist assessment.

They require therapy alongside with transitioning.

Jump in the discussion.

No email address required.

:#marseywoah:

Jump in the discussion.

No email address required.

anti-trans legislation.

I prefer “pro-woman legislation.”

Jump in the discussion.

No email address required.

Boycott harry potter fans bully harry potter fans harass harry potter fans punch harry potter fans.

Jump in the discussion.

No email address required.

The antisemitism angle got its steam in GCJ when they understood that there are not enough train enthusiasts in this world to care about trains

Jump in the discussion.

No email address required.

Stop the goty nominations and sequel, i guess

Jump in the discussion.

No email address required.

Also, what are they even hoping to accomplish at this point? The game is already a massive success and that can't be taken away.

Show their circle that they are still caring and thus are the better/best pro trans people.

Jump in the discussion.

No email address required.

Link copied to clipboard
Action successful!
Error, please refresh the page and try again.