emoji-award-marseywholesome
Unable to load image
Reported by:

Solving the trans athlete problem - what trans women should do instead of what they are doing now

First of all people have to accept the fact, that the male body evolved to be more optimized to do sports which means, that a person with a female body can't compete no matter how much they try, it's unfair, but that's what reality is, and we have to adapt to it, and not ignore when it's incovinient. This gives women who were born with a male body an insane advantage against anyone with a female body, and hormones can't remove this advantage. And the reason there is a seperate "men's sports" and "women's sports" is to seperate the 50% percent of the population into a seperate category who simply wouldn't have a chance against the other 50% so they'll have a fair chance against the other people in their own category, this means they are not actually seperated based on whether they are men or women, but whether they have a biologically male or female body.

So this means that transwomen are women who were born without the physical disavantange that other women weren't born with, and they should not use it to screw over other women, because then they are betraying their own group, they should instead use this power to help other women, and not screw them over. One thing they should do is to play against men in sports, because they actually have a chance that their sisters don't. A woman winning against men is simply awesome, I always love when that happens and sadly most women can't do it in competetive sports, because they were born with a body that is simply not optimized for that, so we now have all trans women who have an optimized body can finally beat the shit out of men, and I wanna see that really much. It only happened yet when the trans woman was hiding that they are actually a woman, like Caitlyn Jenner, but she is such a queen for destoying men as a woman still. It would be much cooler if a trans women did the same when everyone already knows that she is a woman.

Idk, I just really think trans women should use their special power to help women, and not to hurt them. And not just in the case of sports, but they really should focus on protecting women when men want to hurt their sisters. It just really pisses me off, when trans women are on the side of the creepy degenerate man instead of on the side of the woman he is trying to hurt, and all the creepy man had to do is pretend to be trans to get the trans women on their side, those trans women really should just beat the shit out of that degen man and protect their sister, after they realize the deceit by the man.

(Also I did not forget about trans men, I just don't want write even more words, and that's also a way different complex issue.)

29
Jump in the discussion.

No email address required.

Reported by:

YAWN

Jump in the discussion.

No email address required.

For real I barely made it one sentence

Jump in the discussion.

No email address required.

Reported by:
Jump in the discussion.

No email address required.

You shut the frick up! You shut the frick up now!

Jump in the discussion.

No email address required.

the male body evolved to be more optimized to do sports

:marseyxd:

Jump in the discussion.

No email address required.

It was like the hunting and defending against other human tribes and such things just didn't want to explain it with more words.

Jump in the discussion.

No email address required.

So this means that transwomen are women who were born without the physical disavantange that other women weren't born with, and they should not use it to screw over other women, because then they are betraying their own group, they should instead use this power to help other women, and not screw them over.

I think this shows where the real line is. I've noticed that trans women who share this opinion, or any common sense stance like this, get harrased by other trans women. I also can't help but notice the difference in these two groups go beyond opinion.

The ones that have women friendly views tend to actually like women, have women friends, and usually put some effort into passing because they want to be seen ultimately want to be seen as women and not just trans women. They don't invalidate the experinces or pain bio women have gone through. They are allies to women because they know, despite how they may appear to some, they are women too.

Then there's the other side of the coin, and also often the most vocal side. They don't seem to actually like women that much. They limit their view of womanhood to stereotypes and caricatures. They don't care about what bio women have been through or what their lived experinces are because in their minds it will never be as important as those of trans women. Unsurprisingly, they have little to no bio women friends. They are very aggressive about being unconditionally placed and accepted into traditional women's spaces. They usually don't put too much effort into passing because to them it shouldn't matter any way.

In my opinion, first group= trans women. Womanhood is something they feel inside. It's a part of them and they want to be a part of it in society. Second group= AGPs. Womanhood is something to be consumed and conquered. They get great enjoyment out of bending society with their "womanhood" and putting biowomen in their place. Women's best interest are not their interest because deep down inside they don't relate to women, only the trans woman identity.

Jump in the discussion.

No email address required.

I fully agree, once I ended up in a groomercord group full of "trans women" of the second category, and all they mostly just talked about how much they hate women, and about sexually degenerate things, that place totally disgusted me.

Jump in the discussion.

No email address required.

AGP's don't really care for the gendered aspect of women that comprises of behaviors and values specific to whatever culture they're in. They desire to experience living in women's bodies only, which is why they forgo any of the socialization that women(and real transwoman) experience. At most they'll do some token "woman" things to affirm their identity and then promptly go back to speedrunning or whatever neurodivergent hobby they were fixated as men.

The current epidemic of AGP trains is emerging from the larger pool of loser degenerate men that hate women, of which many go on to be hard alt-righters, incels, chapos, and often switch between these groups freely. If you take away their gender and politics (their identities) and see their actions you'll realize they're all very similar.

Jump in the discussion.

No email address required.

:!marseytrain:s need to stick to dilating and stop embarassing themselves whit sports

Jump in the discussion.

No email address required.

Exactly this. Stretch that itchy frick hole and STFU with the demands.

Jump in the discussion.

No email address required.

This gives women who were born with a male body

This has never happened in the history of biology.

Jump in the discussion.

No email address required.

yet there are trans women, so it happens

Jump in the discussion.

No email address required.

Typical transmisic propaganda, usually I won't respond to a bigot like you with 38 entries on your Masstagger's dossier but

When a woman is assigned male at birth it does not mean that her body is male, her body is just a feminine as a cis-woman assigned female at birth. There are multiple scientific evidences of this of which I pointed out in my other post and I won't waste time repeating to a transmisic bigot like you.

You're basically saying that is OK to discriminate against women who were assigned male at birth just because their valid female bodies don't match your stereotypical view of the mythological female body which founds NOT SCIENTIFIC BASIS WHATSOEVER.

"The appropriate response to someone declaring that they don't intend to treat others as though their lives and well-being amount to anything is to get ready to fight them, not debate them."

It's more than different viewpoints. It's disgusting, unethical, fascist-adjacent[1] bigotry and stochiatic terrorism[2] which has led and continues to lead to the literal genocide of trans people (see the UN definition of genocide; USA and UK alone are actively genocidal toward trans people and they're supposedly the "developed world").

Alongside numerous anti-LGBTQ+ hate groups Stock has signed the extremist WHRC/WDI declaration.

For more endless Stock/TERF/GC/transphobe criticisms see Christa Peterso, Katy Montgomerie, Trans Atlantic Call In Show (on The Line channel) and the XX Factor.

GTF0 off with that bigotry. LGBTQ+ existence is not a f#####g thought experiment or up for debate.

Treating our lives as a debate does irreparable damage that lasts and has lasted generations. Privileged people can spend 5min writing lies and bigotry about trans people and go on with their day. We face the material consequences for the rest of our lives.

People need to stop blindly spreading bigotry and further oppressing the most intersectionally oppressed (black, disabled, queer, trans women specifically)

I hope this clears things up.


[1] See Magnus Hirschfeld, Institute of Sexuality, the first Nazi book burning which specifically targeted his trans research, pink triangles, etc.
[2] See Lily Cade for example, Posie Parker encouraging people to shoot trans women in the bathroom, the murder rate of black trans women, trans/gay panic defense, etc.

Jump in the discussion.

No email address required.

HOW DOES IT HAPPEN? IS IT A CASE OF CONJOINED TWINS IN WHICH THE BRAIN OF A FEMALE TWIN IS SUBSUMED INTO THE SKULL OF THE MALE TWIN?

PLEASE EXPLAIN HOW A WOMAN CAN HAVE A MALE BODY AND ISN'T JUST A MALE WITH A MENTAL ILLNESS.

TRANS LIVES MATTER NOT EVEN TOO THEIR PARENTS

Jump in the discussion.

No email address required.

PLEASE EXPLAIN HOW A WOMAN CAN HAVE A MALE BODY AND ISN'T JUST A MALE WITH A MENTAL ILLNESS.

Because is it socially beneficial to treat them as a woman.

Here is an example. Let's say there is 1 dollar bank note, it is worth 1 dollar because society decided it is useful to treat it as it is worth 1 dollar, and to decide that the 5 dollar bank note is worth 5 times as much for example. But if we remove the society part it's just a paper with some picture and text on it, not money, it's the social usefulness that gives them it's value and worth, otherwise people would need to barter, like give a chicken to someone so they give them bread or something like that which is way less convinient, because they could just look at that paper with the picture of Washington, and say it is worthless to them, but they don't, they do define it as money, because of its social usefullness. The same way the reason trans woman are women is because it is socially useful to treat them as such to alleviate the distress caused by their gender dysphoria, Sure the same way as you can call the 1 dollar bank note just a paper with a picture of Washington, you can call trans women just men with the mental illness, but that misses socially useful reason why is good to define that the paper with that picture IS money, and why the trans woman IS a woman.

Jump in the discussion.

No email address required.

Because is it socially beneficial too treat them as a woman.

Socially beneficial too whom? Too them? OK but that doesn't mean @AuntyAbortion is obliged too do literally anything and it definitely doesn't mean they're a "woman born into a male body".

Because trans lives matter only for the purposes of comedy.

Jump in the discussion.

No email address required.

have some empathy, if other people are happy and less distressed that's good, and what is good, there should be more of, simple as that

Jump in the discussion.

No email address required.

The root of it is that @AuntyAbortion want neurodivergent men too suffer so I've got no inclination too ignore reality by pretending that these horrifying r-slurs are women. It simply isn't true that trans lives matter. They don't.

Jump in the discussion.

No email address required.

there is nothing pretending about this, also why you want others to suffer, that's not cool :(

Jump in the discussion.

No email address required.

there is nothing pretending about this

Who are you trying too convince?

Trans lives matter too big pharma but not too anyone else.

Jump in the discussion.

No email address required.

Utilitarianism :marseysick:

Jump in the discussion.

No email address required.

you're fricking bananas if you think I'm reading all that, take my downvote and shut up idiot

Jump in the discussion.

No email address required.

:#marseybased:

Jump in the discussion.

No email address required.

:#marseyshy:

Jump in the discussion.

No email address required.

trans women should use their special power

And what power is this? I don't watch or read much capeshit/superhero/comic book stuff, but I don't think I've ever heard of a power like this?

Jump in the discussion.

No email address required.

That stuff that gives them the unfair advantage in women's sports

Jump in the discussion.

No email address required.

Sweaty, that's nothing to do with their power, it's to do with biofoids lack of power...

Jump in the discussion.

No email address required.

Morphological and chromosomal sexes in Mammalia are a bimodal distribution, not exclusive categories drawn from some Natural Law Eternal Ideals; There are potentially infinite s*x types in humans, and science doesn't prescribe who is "male" and who is "female", only tries to describe the diversity of human sexual types.

Because of this, there are no morphological (nor chromosomal) holotypes nor allotypes for the Homo sapiens taxon -- neither morphological, nor chromosomal, nor genetic, nor epigenetic -- upon which a defensible, "Scientific" or "Biological" axiomatic claim of "S*x" being exclusively, binarily, "Male" or "Female" could rest.

There's an "XY-chromosomed" woman carrying to term her first child; There is scientific literature demonstrating that women with XY predominant chromosome typing can reproduce. There are XX men, women with Klinefelter, men with Klinefelter, non-binary human beings with Klinefelter.

This is an editorial by the editors of Nature, the single highest citation index scientific periodical in the world, supporting this fact, and relating it to gender, a social construct related to biological differences but also rooted in culture, societal norms and individual behaviour.

A genetic typing test does not determine whether someone is "sexually" or socially a man or a woman!

The rhetorical formation of "Biological women" is not supported scientifically, and is a rhetorical formation that signifies "Only cisgender women, and never transgender women", in a manner which the person using it hopes allows them to escape negative consequences for hatred of, and discrimination against, transgender women. The reduction of men and women to "xx" and "xy" is as scientifically defensible, and as hatefully ideologically motivated, as reducing the determination of who is and who is not "human" via relegating certain ethnicities to "throwbacks", "subhumans", "neanderthals" or "troglodytes" by examining their cheekbones or "cranial capacities".

So, here's the thing:

We transgender people have science, and scientists, and medical science, and psychiatry, and biology, and biologists, and our medical doctors on our side.

And bigots have a lot of people who are weaponising the Fallacy of Composition, platforming nonsense pseudo-science, and allying with theocratic queermisic, homomisic, transmisic violent fascists to demand that we are legally treated as subhuman, while repeating literal Nazi propaganda, being racist against aboriginal peoples and their cultures, and calling transgender people a cult.

This is not a debate subreddit. This is not a soapbox subreddit. The hateful talking points of bigots are not platformed here, not given credence here, not lent credibility by being "seriously considered" in a manner that belies the fact that they're exactly as credible as the bigots who put people to death for saying the world is 6 billion years old, or persecuted scientists for saying that humans evolved from a common ancestor with other modern primates.

Jump in the discussion.

No email address required.

this reminded me of I so hate that the liberal/the left went so antiscience, like right now both of the political sides ignore science, and only accept what they wish was reality

Jump in the discussion.

No email address required.

like right now both of the political sides ignore science, and only accept what they wish was reality

It's been like that for decades, sweaty. Way before the US creationists were fighting to teach their religious story in public schools.

They use "science" whenever it's convenient.

Jump in the discussion.

No email address required.

All them words won't bring your pa back.

Jump in the discussion.

No email address required.

DEMAnd Access tTO, ONline """HAIRY BUTT DINGLEBEARRY BUFFet""" RESTORE My Access IMMEDATELY!!!! Did Not HAeve PErmission, BAN From ASsbuffet. FIX IT NOW Thx;

Jump in the discussion.

No email address required.

I don't remember asking rdrama to solve societies problems. We're here to watch the drama not stop it

Jump in the discussion.

No email address required.

I mean this doesn't really fit what either of the political sides would want so it would probably cause drama

Jump in the discussion.

No email address required.

and they should not use it to screw over other women, because then they are betraying their own group

I finally get to use this trite saying:

The cruelty is the point.

Jump in the discussion.

No email address required.

trans women beat women

Jump in the discussion.

No email address required.

(Also I did not forget about trans men, I just don't want write even more words, and that's also a way different complex issue.)

Not really, have them both compete with men

Jump in the discussion.

No email address required.

:tayclap:

Jump in the discussion.

No email address required.

Sorry, my uni already passed a resolution to put the swim coach through a reeducation program.

Jump in the discussion.

No email address required.

WHAT'S WITH ALL THE AUT1STIC LONGPOSTING GOING ON?

DID PIZZASHILL HAVE CHILDREN AND NOW THEY'RE ALL GROWN UP AND POSTING ON DRAMA.NET??

Jump in the discussion.

No email address required.

Link copied to clipboard
Action successful!
Error, please refresh the page and try again.